Over the past decade, HCI researchers and practitioners have increasingly addressed ethics-focused issues through a range of theoretical, methodological, and pragmatic contributions to the field. While many forms of design knowledge have been proposed and described, we focus explicitly on knowledge that has been codified as “methods,” which we define as structured supports for everyday work practices of designers. In this article, we identify, analyze, and map a collection of 63 existing methods intentionally designed for ethical impact. Building on results of a content analysis of these methods, we contribute a descriptive record of how these methods operationalize ethics, their intended audience or context of use, their “core” or “script,” and the means by which these methods are formulated and codified. Building on these results, we provide an initial definition of ethics-focused methods, identifying potential opportunities for the development of future methods to support ethical design practice.
Design and technology practitioners are increasingly aware of the ethical impact of their work practices, desiring tools to support their ethical awareness across a range of contexts. In this paper, we report on findings from a series of six co-creation workshops with 26 technology and design practitioners that supported their creation of a bespoke ethics-focused action plan. Using a qualitative content analysis and thematic analysis approach, we identified a range of roles and process moves that practitioners and design students with professional experience employed and illustrate the interplay of these elements that impacted the creation of their action plan and revealed aspects of their ethical design complexity. We conclude with implications for supporting ethics in socio-technical practice and opportunities for the further development of methods that support ethical engagement and are resonant with the realities of practice.
20 June 2024 in ACM Journal on Responsible Computing
Ethics as embodied by technology practitioners resists simple definition—particularly as it relates to the interplay of identity, organizational, and professional complexity. In this article, we use the linguistic notion of languaging as an analytic lens to describe how technology and design practitioners negotiate their conception of ethics as they reflect upon their everyday work. We engaged 12 practitioners in individual co-creation workshops, encouraging them to reflect on their ethical role in their everyday work through a series of generative and evaluative activities. We analyzed these data to identify how each practitioner reasoned about ethics through language and artifacts, finding that practitioners used a range of rhetorical tropes to describe their ethical commitments and beliefs in ways that were complex and sometimes contradictory. Across three cases, we describe how ethics was negotiated through language across three key zones of ecological emergence: the practitioners’ “core” beliefs about ethics, internal and external ecological elements that shaped or mediated these core beliefs, and the ultimate boundaries they reported refusing to cross. Building on these findings, we describe how the languaging of ethics reveals opportunities to definitionally and practically engage with ethics in technology ethics research, practice, and education.
12 March 2025 in ACM Transactions on Social Computing
Designers’ use of deceptive and manipulative design practices have become increasingly ubiquitous, impacting users’ ability to make choices that respect their agency and autonomy. These practices have been popularly defined through the term dark patterns , which has gained attention from designers, privacy scholars, and, more recently, legal scholars and regulators. The increased interest in the concept of dark patterns across a range of practitioners and users motivated us to study the evolution of the concept and highlight the future trajectory of conversations around dark patterns and similar activist movements that utilize social computing platforms. In this article, we examine the history and evolution of the Twitter (currently known as X) discourse around #darkpatterns from its inception in June 2010 until April 2021, using a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods to describe how this discourse has changed over time. We frame these conversations through a new concept of socio-technical activism , whereby participants unite to identify and fight back against problematic technology and design practices. We discuss the potential future trajectories of this discourse and opportunities for further social computing scholarship at the intersection of design, policy, and online activism.
1 April 2021 in Journal of Physics: Conference Series
With the gradual popularization of the mobile Internet and the Internet of Things, people’s lifestyles have undergone profound changes. In the medical field, the demand for smart medical remote care is gradually increasing. The continuous upgrading and updating of medical equipment and the precision operation of inspection equipment have made medical information systems contain more and more types of data. Based on data lifecycle management theory and big data processing technology such as Hadoop, this paper designs a corresponding data lifecycle management model for children’s chronic kidney disease remote rehabilitation system. Its role is to manage the data reasonably, thereby increasing the availability of information systems and improving the efficiency of system storage devices.