Catherine R. Butler

Catherine R. Butler

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Catherine R. Butler

Division of Nephrology, Department of Medicine and the Kidney Research Institute University of Washington Seattle Washington USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

11Years (2016-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 February 2021 in JAMA Internal Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
CBCatherine R. Butler
Catherine R. Butler
AWAaron Wightman
Aaron Wightman
CRClaire A. Richards
Claire A. Richards
RLRyan S. Laundry
Ryan S. Laundry
JTJanelle S. Taylor
Janelle S. Taylor
AOAnn M. O’hAre
Ann M. O’hAre
Kidney transplant is a preferred treatment for end-stage kidney disease.1,2 However, because there are risks associated with transplant and the supply of donor organs is limited, patients are required to participate in a formal medical and psychosocial evaluation before they can be added to the deceased donor transplant waiting list or can be accepted for a transplant from a living donor. Once selected, patients may spend years on the national waiting list before receiving a transplant from a deceased donor. During this time, they are closely monitored by the transplant center for signs of deteriorating health and/or the development of new contraindications to transplant.

25 March 2021 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CBCatherine R Butler
Catherine R Butler
SWSusan P Y Wong
Susan P Y Wong
EVElizabeth K Vig
Elizabeth K Vig
CNClaire S Neely
Claire S Neely
AOAnn M O'HAre
Ann M O'HAre
Objective The COVID-19 pandemic has transformed healthcare delivery in the USA, but there has been little empirical work describing the impact of these changes on clinicians. We conducted a study to address the following question: how has the pandemic impacted US clinicians’ professional roles and relationships? Design Inductive thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews. Setting Clinical settings across the USA in April and May of 2020. Participants Clinicians with leadership and/or clinical roles during the COVID-19 pandemic. Measures Emergent themes related to professional roles and relationships. Results Sixty-one clinicians participated in semi-structured interviews. Study participants were practising in 15 states across the USA, and the majority were White physicians from large academic centres. Three overlapping and inter-related themes emerged from qualitative analysis of interview transcripts: (1) disruption: boundaries between work and home life became blurred and professional identity and usual clinical roles were upended; (2) constructive adaptation: some clinicians were able to find new meaning in their work and described a spirit of collaboration, shared goals, open communication and mutual respect among colleagues; and (3) discord and estrangement: other clinicians felt alienated from their clinical roles and experienced demoralising work environments marked by division, value conflicts and mistrust. Conclusions Clinicians encountered marked disruption of their professional roles, identities and relationships during the pandemic to which they and their colleagues responded in a range of different ways. Some described a spirit of collaboration and camaraderie, while others felt alienated by their new roles and experienced work environments marked by division, value conflicts and mistrust. Our findings highlight the importance of effective teamwork and efforts to support clinician well-being during the COVID-19 pandemic.

1 April 2016 in Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CBCatherine R. Butler
Catherine R. Butler
RMRajnish Mehrotra
Rajnish Mehrotra
MTMark R. Tonelli
Mark R. Tonelli
DLDaniel Y. Lam
Daniel Y. Lam
Throughout the history of dialysis, four bioethical principles — beneficence, nonmaleficence, autonomy and justice — have been weighted differently based upon changing forces of technologic innovation, resource limitation, and societal values. In the 1960s, a committee of lay people in Seattle attempted to fairly distribute a limited number of maintenance hemodialysis stations guided by considerations of justice. As technology advanced and dialysis was funded under an amendment to the Social Security Act in 1972, focus shifted to providing dialysis for all in need while balancing the burdens of treatment and quality of life, supported by the concepts of beneficence and nonmaleficence. At the end of the last century, the importance of patient preferences and personal values became paramount in medical decisions, reflecting a focus on the principle of autonomy. More recently, greater recognition that health care financial resources are limited makes fair allocation more pressing, again highlighting the importance of distributive justice. The varying application and prioritization of these four principles to both policy and clinical decisions in the United States over the last 50 years makes the history of hemodialysis an instructive platform for understanding principlist bioethics. As medical technology evolves in a landscape of changing personal and societal values, a comprehensive understanding of an ethical framework for evaluating appropriate use of medical interventions enables the clinician to systematically negotiate and optimize difficult ethical situations.

21 January 2022 in Critical Care Explorations
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CBCatherine R. Md Butler
Catherine R. Md Butler
LWLaura B. Dbe Webster
Laura B. Dbe Webster
VSVicki L. Sakata
Vicki L. Sakata
MTMark R. Md Tonelli
Mark R. Md Tonelli
DDDouglas S. Diekema
Douglas S. Diekema
MGMegan M. Gray
Megan M. Gray
Objectives: Plans for allocating scarce healthcare resources during the COVID-19 pandemic commonly involve the activation of institutional triage teams. These teams would be responsible for selecting patients who are most likely to survive to be prioritized to receive scarce resources. However, there is little empirical support for this approach. Design: High-fidelity triage-team simulation study. Setting: Healthcare institutions in Washington state. SUBJECTS: Triage teams, consisting of at least two senior clinicians and a bioethicist. INTERVENTIONS: Participants reviewed a limited amount of deidentified information for a diverse sample of critically ill patients. Teams then assigned each patient to one of five prioritization categories defined by likelihood of survival to hospital discharge. The process was refined based on observation and participant feedback after which a second phase of simulations was conducted. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Feasibility was assessed by the time required for teams to perform their task. Prognostic accuracy was assessed by comparing teams’ prediction about likelihood of survival to hospital discharge with real-world discharge outcomes. Agreement between the teams on prognostic categorization was evaluated using kappa statistics. Eleven triage team simulations (eight in phase 1 and three in phase 2) were conducted from December 2020 to February 2021. Overall, teams reviewed a median of 23 patient cases in each session (interquartile range [IQR], 17–29) and spent a median of 102 seconds (IQR, 50–268) per case. The concordance between expected survival and real-world survival to discharge was 71% (IQR, 64–76%). The overall agreement between teams for placement of patients into prognostic categories was moderate (weighted kappa = 0.53). Conclusions: These findings support the potential feasibility, accuracy, and effectiveness of institutional triage teams informed by a limited set of patient information items as part of a strategy for allocating scarce resources in healthcare emergencies. Additional work is needed to refine the process and adapt it to local contexts.

25 July 2020 in BMC Nephrology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CBCatherine R. Butler
Catherine R. Butler
JTJanelle S. Taylor
Janelle S. Taylor
PRPeter P. Reese
Peter P. Reese
AOAnn M. O’hAre
Ann M. O’hAre
Background: A potential pitfall of policies intended to promote referral for kidney transplant is that greater numbers of patients may be evaluated for transplant without experiencing the intended benefit of receiving a kidney. Little is known about the potential implications of this experience for patients. Methods: We performed a thematic analysis of clinician documentation in the electronic medical records of all adults at a single medical center with advanced kidney disease who were referred to the local transplant coordinator for evaluation between 2008 and 2018 but did not receive a kidney. Results: 148 of 209 patients referred to the local kidney transplant coordinator at our center (71%) had not received a kidney by the end of follow-up. Three dominant themes emerged from qualitative analysis of documentation in the medical records of these patients: 1) Forward momentum: patients found themselves engaged in an iterative process of testing and treatment that tended to move forward unless an absolute contraindication to transplant was identified or patients disengaged; 2) Potential for transplant shapes other medical decisions: engagement in the transplant evaluation process could impact many other aspects of patients’ care; and 3) Personal responsibility and psychological burden for patients and families: clinician documentation suggested that patients felt personally responsible for the course of their evaluation and that the process could take an emotional toll on them and their family members. Conclusions: Engagement in the kidney transplant evaluation process can be a significant undertaking for patients and families and may impact many other aspects of their care. Policies to promote referral for kidney transplant should be coupled with efforts to strengthen shared decision-making to ensure that the decision to undergo transplant evaluation is framed as an explicit choice with benefits, risks, and alternatives and patients have an opportunity to shape their involvement in this process.

1 July 2022 in Journal of Medical Ethics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
CBCatherine R Butler
Catherine R Butler
LWLaura B Webster
Laura B Webster
DDDouglas S Diekema
Douglas S Diekema
Severe staffing shortages have emerged as a prominent threat to maintaining usual standards of care during the COVID-2019 pandemic. In dire settings of crisis capacity, healthcare systems assume the ethical duty to maximise aggregate population-level benefit of existing resources. To this end, existing plans for rationing mechanical ventilators and intensive care unit beds in crisis capacity focus on selecting individual patients who are most likely to survive and prioritising these patients to receive scarce resources. However, staffing capacity is conceptually different from availability of these types of discrete resources, and the existing strategy of identifying and prioritising patients with the best prognosis cannot be readily adapted to fit this real-world scenario. We propose that two alternative approaches to staffing resource allocation offer a better conceptual fit: (1) prioritise the worst off: restrict access to acute care services and hospital admission for patients at relatively low clinical risk and (2) prioritise staff interventions with high near-term value: universally restrict selected interventions and treatments that require substantial staff time and/or energy but offer minimal near-term patient benefit. These strategies—while potentially resulting in care that deviates from usual standards–support the goal of maximising the aggregate benefit of scarce resources in crisis capacity settings triggered by staffing shortages. This ethical framework offers a foundation to support institutional leaders in developing operationalisable crisis capacity policies that promote fairness and support healthcare workers.