Sirs—Szreter and Woolcock have argued that demographic history has a significant contribution to make in the debate about the role of social capital in shaping health patterns. They illustrate this by focusing on the impact of social welfare on mortality in Britain during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. While agreeing with the authors about the importance of history, we will present evidence to suggest different conclusions about the historical role of social capital.
15 July 2004 in International Journal of Epidemiology
Objective To investigate the association between poverty, birthweight, and infant weight gain in Hertfordshire, 1923–1939. Design Cohort study based on the Hertfordshire Health Visitors' Register (HHVR). Setting The population of Hertfordshire, and a sub-sample of five Hertfordshire towns—Hoddesdon, Berkhampstead, Hertford, Hitchin, and Bishops Stortford—extracted from the HHVR. Subjects Some 71 201 live birth entries in the HHVR and a sample of 13 649 live birth entries for the five towns. Measure of poverty Rateable value of birth addresses reflecting market and rental value of housing Main outcome measures Birthweight, and infant weight gain (z score of weight at one year minus z score of birthweight). Results In Hertfordshire as a whole there was a reduction in mean birthweight from 7.7 pounds (lbs) in 1923 to 7.4 lbs in 1939. Over the same time period there was an increase in mean infant weight gain, although with a degree of variation within the trend. In the sample of five towns there was no association between rateable value and birthweight, but a significant association between rateable value and both weight at one year, and weight gain during the first year of life. Conclusion In Hertfordshire average birthweight declined, whereas weight gain during the first year of life tended to increase, at a time when, nationally, calorific intake and per capita consumption of a range of nutritional ingredients was rising. Poverty, as measured by rateable value, did not correlate with birthweight but was associated with weight gain during the first year of life. These findings suggest that nutritional poverty had a more significant influence on post-natal weight gain than it did on birthweight.
17 August 2005 in International Journal of Epidemiology
There are two main areas of disagreement between Simon Szreter1,2 and ourselves,3 one concerning the evidence on mortality in the 18th and 19th centuries and the other its interpretation.
In 1981, Edward A. Wrigley and Roger S. Schofield published The Population History of England 1541–1871, which has come to be seen as the definitive history of population in the 330-year period bet...