Creating impact in labs oriented at sustainability transformations is challenging. Combining the experiences of ten projects and sharing the insights in “Labbing”, gained through engaging in various activities within transformation-oriented Labs from the fields of agriculture, food, and healthcare, the author team established a Community of Practice at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, to identify impact challenges inductively and recommend practical strategies for addressing these.While the issue of creating impact in real-world labs for experimenting with sustainability transformation has been studied, little is known about how to assess and understand impact in practice. Deciding on “what counts as impact” is challenging as problem definitions and solutions are political and contested. In our research projects for sustainability transformations in fields such as agriculture, food, and healthcare, we encountered typical questions of creating impact in real-world labs. We established a Community of Practice to explore the different challenges pertaining to these impact questions. We identified four overarching challenges related to impact: 1. measuring the impact of Labs, 2. dealing with positionality and power dynamics, 3. fostering impact within and beyond projects, and 4. ensuring impact across different contexts. This paper offers practical strategies for responding to these challenges: 1. tailor-made training for Labbing, 2. reflexively engaging with power dynamics, 3. forging rich, translocal learning and impact. Sharing learnings from our experience with Labbing may broaden the repertoire of fellow Lab practitioners in enhancing and strengthening their impact.
This paper analyses the regional characteristics of food policy networks (FPNs)—multi-sector stakeholder groups that are responding to social, political and ecological challenges facing food systems. As FPNs have grown in number around the globe, there is an absence of comparative research to understand their diversity across regions. In addition, there is scant understanding of how their placed-based characteristics might complicate the picture of an ‘urban food policy council’, raising questions about translocal influences—interventions, coalitions and crises—that impact the emergence of FPNs in regional settings. Drawing on interviews with 67 FPNs from across the world, the paper examines the significance of place and socio-cultural framing on transformative agendas for food systems. Applying a place-based and translocal conceptual lens, the paper asks: how do the regional contexts of FPNs shape their purpose, approach and impact? Can the analysis of diverse regional FPNs from one location contribute new understandings of others towards food systems transformation? How can regional perspectives inform urban food governance research? And how can translocal networks help rescale food system governance? This paper shows that not only are FPNs creating innovative governance structures to identify and tackle regionally contextualised food challenges, but they are also modelling forms of translocal collaboration across silos and sectors while striving for inclusivity beyond an urban-rural dichotomy.