2 March 2020 in Journal of Brand Management
14 September 2023 in International Journal of Market Research
Line Extensions are among the most common form of product launch in packaged goods markets. As part of this process, brand managers must decide the visual design of the new variant’s packaging. To inform this decision making, this research aims to empirically quantify the efficacy of using colors versus images as signals of product variety on pack. We compare the use of color on 576 packs with perceptions of 1,853 category buyers across three categories in the USA. We find that for 84% of variant types, marketers use common colors to signal variety on pack, while consumers perceive that only 56% of variant types are represented by a particular color. Of greater concern, the colors used in practice and those expected by consumers align in only 16% of cases. By comparison, images are linked to variant types to a significantly greater extent (39% of cases). This suggests images are a stronger and more explicit signal of product variety than color. There are multiple implications arising from this study. It expands scholarly research on the use of colors in product extensions and, at the same time, provides a series of valuable benchmarks for industry practice in the portfolio management domain.
14 October 2024 in International Journal of Market Research
This research develops a new metric (PBCM) that can identify products within a portfolio that are eroding visual branding cohesion. We show how this new measure gives results equivalent to consumer evaluations of cohesion, without costly and time intensive data collection. The sampling frame for this research is 10 portfolios from five categories (dry dog food, instant coffee, toothpaste, shower gel and chewing gum) in the United Kingdom. In addition, 626 consumers were surveyed to investigate how PBCM affects a consumer’s ability to match an individual product back to its portfolio and recall the brand name. We find that products from high cohesion portfolios have significantly higher (17%) correct brand recall than those from low cohesion portfolios and are matched back to their portfolio by more than twice as many respondents (79% v 35%), significantly faster (2.3 vs. 3.8 minutes).
19 July 2025 in Journal of Brand Management
This research examines Portfolio Branding Cohesion (PBC) by applying Ward et al.’s (Int J Market Res, 2024) PBC metric (PBCM) to the United Kingdom’s packaged-goods sector, across nine categories, 125 brands, and 1023 products. On average, brands use their branding elements with 65% consistency. We observe significant variations in PBCM across categories, highlighting that visual cohesion depends on the brand. Factors such as an increasing number of visual elements, the presence of sub-brands, and whether the brand is a private label negatively impact PBCM, reducing cohesion across product portfolios. Our findings show that larger portfolios struggle to maintain cohesion, as expansion often introduces inconsistent design elements. Sub-brands typically weaken cohesion, which could affect long-term brand architecture. These insights offer practical implications for marketers, emphasising the need for careful portfolio management, thoughtful sub-brand strategies, and stronger visual identities for private label brands. Strengthening PBCM allows brands to build a cohesive visual identity, boosting consumer recognition and loyalty. In addition, by replicating and extending Ward et al.’s (2024) PBCM, we enhance its validity and reliability across broader contexts.
15 March 2025 in International Journal of Market Research
Faces inherently capture our attention, allowing our brains to quickly determine whether a new individual poses a threat. This natural tendency has been leveraged by brands to attract consumer attention in advertising, but the contribution of a face to attract attention on pack has yet to receive much attention. In this study, we examine whether incorporating a face on product packaging enhances its visibility in online supermarkets. Our research indicates that unlike in advertising, faces do not have a significant positive effect on a packaging visibility in an online shopping context. The likely reason is that the reduction of facial image size to a thumbnail on screen renders them ineffectual as emotion communication devices. Therefore, there is no online attentional advantage that would encourage packs without a face to add one to their pack design, nor is there any disadvantage if packs take a face off their pack in an online setting.