Involving undergraduate students in research has a wide array of benefits, for the students themselves, for the research team, and for the community. In this work, we identify and map research papers from the CS education community that focus on the implementation and evaluation of undergraduate research experiences. Our mapping of 26 papers on the dimensions of population, research components, and evaluation metrics will provide a systematic resource for finding and categorizing research into these experiences, and for identifying gaps in the literature.
There is a growing movement in the education community to re-evaluate grading practices and find ways of evaluating students that are more flexible, equitable, and focused on student growth. A wide variety of alternative evaluation systems have been developed, including mastery grading, specifications grading, contract grading and ungrading. In this work, we perform a systematic literature search to find studies of alternative evaluation models in computer science education. A total of 37 papers were analyzed and coded on three metrics: Intervention, Evaluation, and Population. This map represents a tool for educators to find and evaluate research on alternative evaluation systems, a resource for researchers to identify areas of future research, and a foundation for a future detailed literature analysis. The complete bibliography and literature map are available for download.