Because of the workforce shortage in Japan, the use of home-care robots, or carebots, is increasingly perceived as a realistic option. Developing and implementing these carebots requires careful consideration of the ethical implications for all types of users. Few studies, however, have addressed the ethical principles and concepts involved in carebot use, and consequently, the discussion regarding roboethics in the home-care environment has been inadequate. This questionnaire study explored the relationship between the willingness of home-care professionals to use carebots, their experiences with robots, and their ethical perceptions. The principal factors affecting home-care staff perceptions were perceived benefit, use of personal information, the protection of privacy, and perceptions of risk. While perceived benefit was the common predictor affecting home-care staff willingness to use a robot for the care of all user types, concerns regarding the use of personal information were more prominent for older people.
25 July 2023 in Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics
To date, research on ethical issues regarding care robots for older adults, family caregivers, and care workers has not progressed sufficiently. This study aimed to build a model that universally explains the relationship between the use of care robots and ethical awareness, such as regarding personal information and privacy protection in home care. We examined data obtained from cross-sectional surveys conducted in Japan (n=528), Ireland (n=296), and Finland (n=180). We performed a confirmatory factor analysis by using responses to 11 items related to the ethical use of care robots. We evaluated the model based on the chi-square to degrees of freedom ratio, the comparative fit index, and the root mean square error of approximation. Subsequently, we compared the model with the Akaike's information criterion. Ten items were adopted in the final model. There were 4 factors in the model: 'acquisition of personal information', 'use of personal information for medical and long-term care', 'secondary use of personal information', and 'participation in research and development'. All factor loadings of the final model ranged between 0.63 and 0.92, which were greater than 0.6, showing that the factors had a high influence on the model. The final model was applied to each country; the fit was relatively good in Finland and poor in Ireland. Although the three countries have different geographies, cultures, demographics, and systems, this study showed that the impact of ethical issues regarding the use of care robots in home care can be universally explained by the same model.
Individuals who have dementia with Lewy bodies present various symptoms that differ from those associated with Alzheimer’s disease. Of the several characteristic symptoms of dementia with Lewy bodies, visual hallucinations often appear in the early stages of the disease, and some hallucinations cause people with dementia with Lewy bodies to experience unique difficulties in their daily lives. The aim of this paper is to clarify the visual hallucination-related difficulties experienced by people with dementia with Lewy bodies as well as their coping methods. Participants were 10 people with dementia with Lewy bodies who were living at home, with input also obtained from their family members. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews, and a qualitative content analysis was consequently performed. The qualitative analysis showed four primary difficulties in the period before a patient realizes that their visual hallucinations are a symptom of an underlying disease; these included “feeling something strange is happening” and “restrictions on activities.” Realizing that what they were experiencing was not real was a significant turning point for the participants, with some discovering this by discussing their apparitions with their families. It was consequently determined that, after an individual realizes that their hallucinations are indicative of a more serious condition, two further difficulties arise, including the “inability to discuss the visual hallucinations with friends and family.” With regard to coping methods, some participants reported rearranging their living environments to hide areas where hallucinations commonly appeared. This paper suggests that care is needed to help people with dementia with Lewy bodies recognize that their visual hallucinations are a manifestation of their illness. In particular, psychological support should be made available to address the anxiety caused by the appearance of visual hallucinations and to help patients adjust their environments to reduce or prevent the appearance of such hallucinations.
Aims: To synthesise the current research on long‐term care workers' perceptions (i.e., attitudes, concerns, and expected functions) of robot‐assisted care and their perceived effects of different types of robot‐assisted care for older adults in long‐term care facilities. Design: Scoping review. Data Sources: A search was conducted in July 2024 using five databases. Articles published between 2010 and 2024 on the perceptions and/or perceived effects of robot‐assisted care for older adults among frontline long‐term care workers in long‐term care facilities were identified. Additionally, the reference lists of the included articles were manually searched. Methods: A five‐step framework that guided the development of research questions, screening of studies, and synthesis and presentation of data was adopted. Two authors independently screened and analysed the identified articles. Conflicts were resolved through joint‐discussions. Results: Forty‐one articles were included in the review. Data were narratively synthesised into three categories: expected function of care robots, perceived effects of robot‐assisted care, and attitudes and concerns regarding robot‐assisted care. Subcategories were identified and presented in tabular form. Conclusion: This review shows the physical, psychological, social, and practical benefits and limitations of different types of robot‐assisted care. It also contributes to understanding long‐term care workers' attitudes, concerns, and expectations regarding the function of robot‐assisted care. Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care: Having a priori discussion with long‐term care workers about their expectations regarding using robot‐assisted care is needed. Improvements in the design and in the digital literacy of the workers are also necessary. Impact: This review provides an overview of the perceptions and perceived effects of different types of robot‐assisted care among care workers in long‐term care facilities. The findings provide practical implications and highlight areas in need of further studies. Reporting Method: Scoping Review (PRISMA‐ScR) checklist. Patient or Public Contribution: No Patient or Public Contribution.