28 May 2022 in Journal of Organizational Behavior
Summary: Adopting an intra‐individual process, we explore the dynamics that underlie the emergence of a psychological contract breach. Thirty‐seven unique storylines expose how selected stimuli shake employees' psychological contracts to attention and give rise to perceptions of breach as a result of an iterative process of disrupting (introducing triggers that prompt a shift from automatic processing to conscious attention of psychological contract terms), appraisal (revealing elements—goals, attribution, fairness, and resources—playing a role in appraising and making sense of triggers), and (problem‐focused and emotion‐focused) coping. We discuss the implications of accounting for breach in the absence of a discrete event and draw on selective attention theory to differentiate when stimuli become triggers with the capacity to activate the psychological contract. We extend existing research by revealing the unique role that triggers, and their interconnectedness play in the cognition of contract breach, building up pressure until a threshold has been surpassed and breach is perceived. Our study highlights the need for managers to use strategies to deescalate the accumulation of triggers.
8 May 2023 in Group & Organization Management
JCJacqueline A-M. Coyle-Shapiro
Jacqueline A-M. Coyle-Shapiro
Psychological contracts reside in the eye of the beholder and capture the employee-employer exchange relationship. It is a dynamic relationship as employees deliberately manage and change their psychological contract over time. Triggers seem to be the drivers underpinning this dynamism. Yet little is known about how these triggers operate and affect the psychological contract. To address this, we explore triggers and their impact using a 6-week daily diary study ( N = 117). We found a linear chain of positive relationships from initial triggers to connectedness of past triggers, to the experience of negative emotions, to the expected reoccurrence of the initial trigger, ultimately disrupting the psychological contract. The findings revealed the dynamic effect of triggers on the employment relationship, not only by exposing the underlying micro-processes, but also by revealing that the impact of triggers can linger for approximately 11 days before leveling off. These findings suggest that the psychological contract may fluctuate on a daily basis due to the influence of triggers. The theoretical implications for understanding the dynamic nature of the psychological contract are discussed in relation to the disruptive role of triggers.
1 January 2016 in Academy of Management Proceedings
Psychological contracts are dynamic. This paper contributes to the understanding of psychological contract dynamics in relation to the impact of organizational changes, by testing a dynamic temporal framework, which consequently highlights the role of trigger events, the appraisal process, goal- setting and coping on the psychological contract. In total 23 semi-structured interviews following Critical Incident Technique were carried out to in three department at three Universities of Applied Sciences in the Netherlands. Focusing empirically on evolving phenomena enables the exploration of temporal progressions of activities as elements of explanation and understanding. The findings highlight the process nature of psychological contracts in organizational change and, in particular the temporal, intra- individual dynamic process of recontracting. This paper contributes to the literature of breach by allowing better understanding of the source of breach by adding triggers to the concept. Although the depth and width of disruptions strongly influences the rest of the change process, limited attention has thus far been paid to the source of the dynamics, the nature of the trigger, how this affects employees’ psychological contracts and what determines their possible impact. Although the data are very rich, the limited sample size limits generalizability. Further research should focus on replicating results in other settings and testing the model in quantitative longitudinal as well as experimental setups. The proposed framework is of value to practitioners involved in large scale reorganizations by developing a better and deeper understanding of employees’ responses and by identifying possible strategies to facilitate organizational change.