Sicily, situated at the heart of the Mediterranean Sea, has been a crossroads of people of different origins since the Paleolithic. To gain further insight into the genetic history of this island from a matrilineal viewpoint, we investigated 15 millennia of human mitogenome evolution. A unique Sicilian mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) dataset, represented by 116 ancient mitogenomes (including two newly sequenced) collected from 16 archeological sites dating from 14,700 to 545 years ago, was compared with a collection of 236 modern mitogenomes covering all districts of the island. By integrating demographic modeling with phylogeographic analyses, we identified a statistically supported genetic discontinuity between the Paleolithic/Late Mesolithic and Early Neolithic periods and two mtDNA lineages (U5b and U8b/K) that specifically mark this transition. The extensive variation and lack of genetic structure among modern mitogenomes suggest the presence of a continuous, maternally inherited gene flow from different regions of Western Eurasia (since the Paleolithic) and Africa (since the Bronze Age).
Historically, the eastern Italian Alps have provided crucial geographic corridors for cultural and genetic exchange between the Mediterranean region and Central and Northern Europe. Although recent archaeogenomic data suggest a strong regional persistence of Anatolian Neolithic ancestry followed by the arrival of Yamnaya-related components during the Bronze Age, the genomic landscape of modern Alpine populations remains largely unmapped. In this study, we verified the persistence of these signals in the present-day Rendena and Ledro Valleys by integrating novel complete mitochondrial genomes (N=185) and genome-wide SNP data (N=96), the latter combined with a novel Italian genomic dataset (N=139). Our findings show that the Rendena and Ledro populations form a distinct “modern Alpine” genomic group, which retains a significant proportion of early European Neolithic ancestry, aligning with ancient eastern Italian Alpine individuals and modern Sardinians. More recently, geographic isolation and localized genetic drift appear to have shaped the two valleys differently. Demographic reconstructions reveal asynchronous population declines over the past two millennia, followed by a sharp, synchronized bottleneck 200-300 years ago, which coincided with historical plague outbreaks. Remarkably, this structured drift persisted at an extremely fine microgeographic scale within the valleys, resulting in internal genetic subclusters that directly correlate with local topography. This micro-differentiation was likely maintained by steep geographic barriers and/or local endogamous practices. This study ultimately underscores how geographic barriers and isolation can preserve ancient genomic components and shape highly localized genetic structures over centuries even to the modern day.