20 July 2020 in Scientific Reports
Humans are placing more strain on the world’s oceans than ever before. Furthermore, marine ecosystems are seldom subjected to single stressors, rather they are frequently exposed to multiple, concurrent stressors. When the combined effect of these stressors is calculated and mapped through cumulative impact assessments, it is often assumed that the effects are additive. However, there is increasing evidence that different combinations of stressors can have non-additive impacts, potentially leading to synergistic and unpredictable impacts on ecosystems. Accurately predicting how stressors interact is important in conservation, as removal of certain stressors could provide a greater benefit, or be more detrimental than would be predicted by an additive model. Here, we conduct a meta-analysis to assess the prevalence of additive, synergistic, and antagonistic stressor interaction effects using seagrasses as case study ecosystems. We found that additive interactions were the most commonly reported in seagrass studies. Synergistic and antagonistic interactions were also common, but there was no clear way of predicting where these non-additive interactions occurred. More studies which synthesise the results of stressor interactions are needed to be able to generalise interactions across ecosystem types, which can then be used to improve models for assessing cumulative impacts.
1 August 2021 in Science of The Total Environment
2 April 2025 in Energy Policy
6 March 2025 in Ocean & Coastal Management
1 September 2019 in Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology
23 June 2026 in SSRN Electronic Journal
Site selection for offshore development must balance environmental conditions with development and operating costs to maximize long-term viability. For example, a site with favourable conditions may contain existing users that will be displaced. Cumulative impact analyses often inform on the environmental risk of offshore development but rarely provide an industry perspective to find compromises in profitability and reducing conflict during site selection. Here, we develop a framework that evaluates site selection trade-offs between environmental suitability and conflict risk for two rapidly expanding offshore industries; wind farming and aquaculture. We identified environmentally suitable areas, then calculated the cumulative risk of conflict based on overlap with existing ocean users, infrastructure and socio-economic impacts. Finally, we combined environmental suitability with cumulative conflict risk to assess the economic viability of offshore wind and aquaculture depending on four planning scenarios: (1) minimising conflict risk, (2) maximising environmental suitability, (3) random site selection, and (4) balancing risk and suitability. We found that prioritising reduced conflict risk reduces costs associated with user displacement. Balancing environmental suitability and reducing conflict risk yielded similar suitability scores across all industries. Offshore wind had the greatest potential to maximise environmental suitability and minimise conflict risk, while aquaculture showed greater trade-offs between objectives. Our findings provide an adaptable approach to help inform site selection decisions to increase offshore development viability. Better understanding the relationship between environmental suitability and cumulative conflict risk helps inform better siting decisions to support long term economic viability of offshore operations, ultimately supporting sustainable blue economy growth.