5 August 2021 in BMJ Open
Background Reporting of yoga research often lacks the detail required for clinical application, study replication, summary research and comparative effectiveness studies. Methods To improve the transparency of reporting yoga interventions, and building on the development of previous reporting guidelines, a group of international yoga research stakeholders developed the consensus-based CheckList stAndardising the Reporting of Interventions For Yoga (CLARIFY) guidelines. Results The 21-item CLARIFY checklist outlines the minimum details considered necessary for high-quality reporting of yoga research. This paper provides a detailed explanation of each of the 21 items of the CLARIFY checklist, together with model examples of how to integrate each item into publications of yoga research. The CLARIFY guideline serves as an extension for existing research reporting guidelines, and is flexible for use across all study designs. Conclusion We strongly encourage the uptake of these reporting guidelines by researchers and journals, to facilitate improvements in the transparency and utility of yoga research.
1 October 2018 in Interactive Journal of Medical Research
Journal of Medical Internet Research - International Scientific Journal for Medical Research, Information and Communication on the Internet #Preprint #PeerReviewMe: Warning: This is a unreviewed preprint. Readers are warned that the document has not been peer-reviewed by expert/patient reviewers or an academic editor, may contain misleading claims, and is likely to undergo changes before final publication, if accepted, or may have been rejected/withdrawn. Readers with interest and expertise are encouraged to sign up as peer-reviewer, if the paper is within an open peer-review period. Please cite this preprint only for review purposes or for grant applications and CVs (if you are the author). Background: Dietary supplements are the most used complementary and alternative health modality in the U.S., and omega-3 supplements continue to be the most popularly used non-vitamin/non-mineral supplements by adults. Supplement users report that they obtain health guidance from internet media resources, but there is question as to whether or not these resources provide the necessary evidence to guide health decisions. Current evidence suggests that there is a mistranslation occurring somewhere between researchers and the media. Objective: We conducted a comparative cross-sectional analysis to identify areas of discordance created when science is translated from the lab to online news media. Methods: A Google news search provided our convenience sample of 40 omega-3 supplement based media reports stratified by the years 2009-2012. Media reports (n = 17) were compared to the corresponding scientific article for content. Report and article content was extracted using commonly accepted reporting guideline domains, and domains were then compared to detect underlying omissions or mistranslations in reporting. Mean scores for all of the scientific articles and media reports were assessed for each domain. Results: Scientific articles generally maintained a mean close to complete (0.85) for each reporting domain. Media reports were far more likely to report potential caveats and warnings for consumers with a mean domain for Caveat reporting of 0.88, (95%CI[0.72, 1.0]). Conclusions: There are inherent differences in the intended audience, structure, and goals in scientific and media communications. These differences should be explored further, and consumers should be made aware of them. Additional considerations for balanced reporting and reader accessibility are also necessary to take into account, and are explored further in this analysis.
7 March 2025 in Journal of Integrative and Complementary Medicine
CCChristine Cherpak-Castagna
Christine Cherpak-Castagna
Introduction: Low rates of online health literacy put consumers at risk of misinformation, but this could be mitigated through practitioner engagement. Integrative health (IH) crosses health care disciplines, so it is well-positioned to improve health information sharing. IH practitioners require evidence-based medicine (EBM) and electronic health literacy (eHL) competencies to make such impact. Several EBM assessments exist, but none are IH-specific. The Fresno Test of EBM FEBM is a validated, performance-based assessment used in medical education. We sought to assess feasibility of incorporating eHL and EBM assessments into graduate coursework while adapting and validating the FEBM for an IH audience (FEBM-IH). Methods: A pilot observational design was used to adapt, evaluate, administer, and validate the FEBM-IH. Revalidation of the FEBM-IH began with a discipline-focused adaptation, which was reviewed by an expert panel. The FEBM-IH was then administered to IH students and faculty. Independently scored assessments determined inter-rater reliability, internal consistency, item discrimination, and item difficulty. eHL assessments (eHEALS and General Health Numeracy Test-6) were also embedded in the online course. Results: Outcome completion rates suggest the FEBM-IH and eHL assessment tools are feasible to include in online courses, with 68.9% (102/148) eligible participants joining and 76.5% (78/102) completing all questions in all measures. The FEBM-IH demonstrated excellent assessor agreement (kappa = 0.97, p < 0.001), high internal consistency (α = 0.799), and acceptable item discrimination (0.26–0.68). Median self-perceived eHL scores increased from 30/40 to 33/40 points by course’s end, suggesting some increase in eHL. Conclusions: Tools were feasible to integrate; FEBM-IH maintains acceptable validity; and further exploration of the relationship between EBM and eHL is warranted.
30 January 2024 in JMIR Preprints
BACKGROUND A core competency of integrative health (IH) education is applying evidence to clinical practice. Low rates of online health literacy put consumers at higher risk of misinformation. Practitioners may serve to reduce this risk. Integrative Health (IH) crosses multiple healthcare disciplines and is therefore well-suited to improve the health information ecosystem. IH practitioners must demonstrate evidence-based medicine (EBM) skills and electronic health information literacy (eHL) to make a positive impact. The Fresno Test of Evidence-Based Medicine (FEBM) is a validated, performance-based assessment used in medical education. However, the scenarios included in this assessment do not reflect IH practices. OBJECTIVE This study used a multi-phase pilot observational design to assess feasibility of incorporating eHL and EBM assessments into graduate coursework while adapting and validating the FEBM for an IH audience (FEBM-IH). METHODS Re-validation of the FEBM-IH began with a discipline-focused adaptation, which was reviewed by an expert panel. The FEBM-IH was then administered to IH students and faculty. Independently scored assessments determined inter-rater reliability, internal consistency, item discrimination, and item difficulty. RESULTS Outcome completion rates suggest the FEBM-IH and eHL assessment tools are feasible (>64% completion) to include in online courses, with 68.9% (102/148) eligible participants joining and 76.5% (78/102) completing all questions in all measures. The FEBM-IH demonstrated excellent assessor agreement (kappa = 0.97, p < 0.001), high internal consistency (α=0.799), and acceptable item discrimination (0.26-0.68). CONCLUSIONS Self-perceived eHL scores showed a 3-point increase in median score by course’s end, suggesting improvements in eHL. Tools were feasible to integrate; FEBM-IH maintains acceptable validity; and further exploration of the relationship between EBM and eHL is warranted. CLINICALTRIAL NA- Not a Clinical Trial
15 September 2017 in JMIR Preprints
BACKGROUND Dietary supplements are the most used complementary and alternative health modality in the U.S., and omega-3 supplements continue to be the most popularly used non-vitamin/non-mineral supplements by adults. Supplement users report that they obtain health guidance from internet media resources, but there is question as to whether or not these resources provide the necessary evidence to guide health decisions. Current evidence suggests that there is a mistranslation occurring somewhere between researchers and the media. OBJECTIVE We conducted a comparative cross-sectional analysis to identify areas of discordance created when science is translated from the lab to online news media. METHODS A Google news search provided our convenience sample of 40 omega-3 supplement based media reports stratified by the years 2009-2012. Media reports (n = 17) were compared to the corresponding scientific article for content. Report and article content was extracted using commonly accepted reporting guideline domains, and domains were then compared to detect underlying omissions or mistranslations in reporting. Mean scores for all of the scientific articles and media reports were assessed for each domain. RESULTS Scientific articles (n=14) generally maintained a mean close to complete for each reporting domain. The only domain where there was not a significant difference between Media and Scientific reporting match was within the Objectives domain (x2 = 0.832, p = 0.362). Media reports (n=17) more frequently reported potential caveats and warnings for consumers with a mean domain for Caveat reporting of 0.88, with possible scores falling between 0 and 1. CONCLUSIONS There are inherent differences in the intended audience, structure, and goals in scientific and media communications. These differences should be explored further, and consumers should be made aware of them. Additional considerations for balanced reporting and reader accessibility are also necessary to take into account, and are explored further in this analysis.