19 November 2021 in IEEE Control Systems Letters
This letter deals with a novel variant of antithetic integral feedback controller (AIFC) motifs which can feature robust perfect adaptation, a pervasive (desired) ability in natural (synthetic) biomolecular circuits, when coupled with a wide class of process networks to be regulated. Using the separation of time-scales in the proposed kind of AIFC, here we find a reduced-order controller that captures the governing slow part of the original solutions under suitable assumptions. Inspired by Rössler systems, we then make use of such a simpler controller to show that the antithetic circuit can exhibit chaotic behaviors with strange attractors, where the bifurcation from a homeostatic state to chaotic orbits can happen, e.g., when considering saturated Hill-type reactions for the actuation. Addition of degradation terms to the controller species, whether naturally due to dilution or exogenously using protein tags, is showcased by simulation results to be an effective solution in suppressing deterministic chaos and aperiodic oscillations. In the same vein, we recapitulate the recently introduced antithetic rein IFC motif and confirm that the promotion of degradation by a rein mechanism also can control chaos and improve the stability of closed-loop circuit.
17 November 2020 in IEEE Transactions on Control of Network Systems
In addition to perfectly steering the output concentration of a process network to an exogenous set-point, a desired synthetically implemented biological controller should be able to robustly maintain this regulated output in the face of the extrinsic disturbances and inherent uncertainties due to an evervarying environment besides the imprecise modeling. Such an ability, which is called robust perfect adaptation (RPA), can be achieved by integral feedback control (IFC). Answering how IFC is (biochemically) constructible in generally unknown synthetic networks has been a research focus in the community. One of these answers, which has been well investigated previously, is to utilize a simple (Hill-type) integral negative feedback controller. Another effective solution, which has made significant progress, is the increasingly being used antithetic integral feedback controller. In this paper, by applying these two RPA-achieving controllers in control of an uncertain process network with arbitrary number of species, the behavior of the resulted closed-loop systems, in which the effect of molecular dilution is also considered, is analyzed. Through this analysis, by assuming that the stability is preserved, it is shown that the latter controller can be approximately reduced to the former (simpler) one by individually increasing one of its parameters (the annihilation rate). Furthermore, to address the stability assumption, exact parametric conditions are derived to guarantee the stability of the control systems. These findings can lead us to gain a deeper insight into and to simplify the robust design, performance analysis, and implementation of such living circuits. Simulation results accompany the paper's analytical elaborations.
21 March 2025 in ACS Synthetic Biology
Integral feedback control strategies have proven effective in regulating protein expression in unpredictable cellular environments. These strategies, grounded in model-based designs and control theory, have advanced synthetic biology applications. Autocatalytic integral feedback controllers, utilizing positive autoregulation for integral action, are one class of simplest architectures to design integrators. This class of controllers offers unique features, such as robustness against dilution effects and cellular growth, as well as the potential for synthetic realizations across different biological scales, owing to their similarity to self-regenerative behaviors widely observed in nature. Despite this, their potential has not yet been fully exploited. One key reason, we discuss, is that their effectiveness is often hindered by resource competition and context-dependent couplings. This study addresses these challenges using a multilayer feedback strategy. Our designs enabled population-level integral feedback and multicellular integrators, where the control function emerges as a property of coordinated interactions distributed across different cell populations coexisting in a multicellular consortium. We provide a generalized mathematical framework for modeling resource competition in complex genetic networks, supporting the design of intracellular control circuits. The use of our proposed multilayer autocatalytic controllers is examined in two typical control tasks that pose significant relevance to synthetic biology applications: concentration regulation and ratiometric control. We define a ratiometric control task and solve it using a variant of our controller. The effectiveness of our controller motifs is demonstrated through a range of application examples, from precise regulation of gene expression and gene ratios in embedded designs to population growth and coculture composition control in multicellular designs within engineered microbial ecosystems. These findings offer a versatile approach to achieving robust adaptation and homeostasis from subcellular to multicellular scales.
31 October 2024 in IEEE Control Systems Letters
Precise intracellular regulation and robust perfect adaptation can be achieved using biomolecular integral controllers and it holds enormous potential for synthetic biology applications. In this letter, we consider the cascaded implementation of a class of such integrator motifs. Our cascaded integrators underpin proportional-integral-derivative (PID) control structures, which we leverage to suggest ways to improve dynamic performance. Moreover, we demonstrate how our cascaded strategy can be harnessed to enhance robust stability in a class of uncertain reaction networks. We also discuss the genetic implementation of our controllers and the natural occurrence of their cascaded sequestration pairs in bacterial pathogens.
22 August 2024 in bioRxiv
Integral feedback control strategies have proven effective in regulating protein expression in unpredictable cellular environments. These strategies, grounded in model-based designs and control theory, have advanced synthetic biology applications. Autocatalytic integral feed-back controllers, utilizing positive autoregulation for integral action, are particularly promising due to their similarity to natural behaviors like self-replication and positive feedback seen across biological scales. However, their effectiveness is often hindered by resource competition and context-dependent couplings. This study addresses these challenges with a multi-layer feedback strategy, enabling population-level integral feedback and multicellular integrators. We provide a generalized mathematical framework for modeling resource competition in complex genetic networks, supporting the design of intracellular control circuits. Our controller motif demonstrated precise regulation in tasks ranging from gene expression control to population growth in multi-strain communities. We also explore a variant capable of ratiometric control, proving its effectiveness in managing gene ratios and co-culture compositions in engineered microbial ecosystems. These findings offer a versatile approach to achieving robust adaptation and homeostasis from subcellular to multicellular scales.