12 December 2025 in The Cryosphere
Sea-ice thickness, though critical to our understanding of sea-ice variability, remains relatively understudied compared to surface sea-ice parameters in the Southern Ocean. To remedy this, we examine spatio-temporal variations in sea-ice thickness by analyzing historical simulations from 39 coupled climate models in CMIP6, comparing them with three sea-ice products, including satellite-derived observations and reanalyses. Furthermore, we compare seasonal trends in simulated sea-ice thickness with trends in sea-ice area. Our results indicate that CMIP6 models can replicate the mean seasonal cycle and spatial patterns of sea-ice thickness. During its maximum in February, these models align well with satellite-based observation products. However, during the annual minima, CMIP6 models show significant agreement with the reanalysis products. Certain models exhibit unrealistic historical mean states compared to the sea-ice products resulting in significant inter-model spread. CMIP6 models can simulate sea-ice area more accurately than the sea-ice thickness. They also simulate a positive relationship between the two parameters in September such that models with greater area tend to exhibit thicker ice. In contrast, there is a negative relationship in February when greater area is associated with lower thickness since only the thicker ice survives the summer melt. Moreover, our study highlights significant positive trends in sea-ice thickness observed during the cooler seasons, which are nearly absent in the warmer seasons where positive trends are predominantly observed in sea-ice area. The spatial distribution of SIT biases is closely linked to uncertainties in modeling the ice edge and the dynamic processes, emphasizing the need for better model representation of both. This study, therefore, highlights the need for improved representation of Antarctic sea-ice processes in models for accurate projections of thickness and related volume changes.
3 April 2025 in EGUsphere
Sea-ice thickness, though critical to our understanding of sea-ice variability, remains relatively understudied compared to surface sea-ice parameters in the Southern Ocean. To remedy this, we examine spatio-temporal variations in sea-ice thickness by analyzing historical simulations from 39 coupled climate models in CMIP6, comparing them with three sea-ice products, including satellite-derived observations and reanalyses. Furthermore, we compare seasonal trends in simulated sea ice thickness with trends in sea ice area. Our results indicate that CMIP6 models can replicate the mean seasonal cycle and spatial patterns of sea-ice thickness. During its maximum in February, these models align well with satellite-based observation products. However, during the annual minima, CMIP6 models show significant agreement with the reanalysis products. Certain models exhibit unrealistic historical mean states compared to the sea-ice products resulting in significant inter-model spread. CMIP6 models can simulate sea-ice area more accurately than the sea-ice thickness. They also simulate a positive relationship between the two parameters in September such that models with greater area tend to exhibit thicker ice. In contrast, there is a negative relationship in February when greater area is associated with lower thickness since only the thicker ice survives the summer melt. Moreover, our study highlights significant positive trends in sea-ice thickness observed during the cooler seasons, which are nearly absent in the warmer seasons where positive trends are predominantly observed in sea-ice area. The spatial distribution of SIT biases is closely linked to uncertainties in modeling the ice edge and the dynamic processes, emphasizing the need for better model representation of both. This study, therefore, highlights the need for improved representation of Antarctic sea-ice processes in models for accurate projections of thickness and related volume changes.
4 September 2024 in EGUsphere
The Arctic sea-ice cover and thickness have rapidly declined in the recent past. Snow cover on sea ice, acting as an insulating barrier, was shown to be instrumental in driving the variability and trends in sea-ice thickness. Because of this, the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the present-day annual cycles of Arctic sea-ice properties has become a central measure of model performance in Arctic-focused climate model intercomparisons. However, evaluating free-running model simulations usually requires multi-year observational datasets, which is challenged by the relatively short-term existing Arctic measurements particularly sea-ice and snow thickness. In this exploratory study, we propose a new methodology to improve the meaningfulness of sea ice and snow comparisons to model data. We make use of the exceptional year-long MOSAiC observations to examine the simulated Arctic sea-ice and snow thickness in 10 CMIP6 models. To perform meaningful comparisons with the modeled simulations, we define two “proxy years” selection methods based on sea-ice area and atmospheric criteria, when these conditions in the Arctic are similar to those during the MOSAiC year. We verify the capability of the proxy-year composites to capture the atmospheric and sea-ice variability, by comparing them with the sets of nudged simulations in which the atmospheric circulation observed during the MOSAiC year is directly imposed. Our results show that models tend to simulate similar annual cycles compared to the observations however, with an overestimation in amplitude for snow thickness and a misaligned phase of sea-ice thickness cycles. Overall, the study highlights that regardless of the specific modeled configurations and conditions within individual proxy years, biases in sea-ice and snow thickness remain consistent, even when wind conditions are imposed in the nudged model simulations. This highlights the necessity for a better representation of modeled processes driving the sea-ice and snow thicknesses which will be instrumental in the next generation of GCMs. This first MOSAiC-based assessment of the modeled snow and ice thickness, and the proposed proxy-year-based methodology, pave the way for further meaningful model evaluation.