8 July 2021 in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
Following the rise of R as a scientific programming language, the increasing requirement for more transferable research and the growth of data availability in hydrology, R packages containing hydrological models are becoming more and more available as an open-source resource to hydrologists. Corresponding to the core of the hydrological studies workflow, their value is increasingly meaningful regarding the reliability of methods and results. Despite package and model distinctiveness, no study has ever provided a comparison of R packages for conceptual rainfall–runoff modelling from a user perspective by contrasting their philosophy, model characteristics and ease of use. We have selected eight packages based on our ability to consistently run their models on simple hydrology modelling examples. We have uniformly analysed the exact structure of seven of the hydrological models integrated into these R packages in terms of conceptual storages and fluxes, spatial discretisation, data requirements and output provided. The analysis showed that very different modelling choices are associated with these packages, which emphasises various hydrological concepts. These specificities are not always sufficiently well explained by the package documentation. Therefore a synthesis of the package functionalities was performed from a user perspective. This synthesis helps to inform the selection of which packages could/should be used depending on the problem at hand. In this regard, the technical features, documentation, R implementations and computational times were investigated. Moreover, by providing a framework for package comparison, this study is a step forward towards supporting more transferable and reusable methods and results for hydrological modelling in R.
11 June 2021 in Hydrological Sciences Journal
Identifying situations where a hydrological model yields poor performance is useful for improving its predictive capability. Here we applied an evaluation methodology to diagnose the weaknesses of a parsimonious rainfall-runoff model for flood simulation. The GR5H-I hourly lumped model was evaluated over a large set of 229 French catchments and 2990 flood events. Model bias was calculated considering different streamflow time windows, from calculations using all observations to analyses of individual flood events. We then analysed bias across seasons and against several flood characteristics. Our results show that although GR5H-I had good overall performance, most of the summer floods were underestimated. In summer and autumn, compensations between flood and recession periods were identified. The largest underestimations of flood volumes were identified when high-intensity precipitation events occurred, especially under low soil moisture conditions.
29 August 2022 in Hydrological Processes
Floods resulting from high‐intensity rainfall events are known to be difficult to simulate. The catchment response to such events is very heterogeneous due to complex combinations of hydrological processes at fine temporal and spatial scales. The goal of this study is to find a way to inform the structure of a hydrological model on the variability in catchment response to rainfall events. To that end, rainfall intensity was used as a proxy for the activation of fast heterogeneous runoff processes. We developed three hypotheses that increase the versatility of a hydrological model by modifying the volume and temporal distribution of effective rainfall when high‐intensity rainfall events occur. These modifications were implemented within the GR5H lumped rainfall–runoff model. The different model versions were run on 229 French catchments where 10 652 flood events were selected. Model performance was assessed considering five groups of catchments, and model performance was also evaluated based on three event characteristics. Results showed that introducing a dynamic dependency of fluxes to rainfall intensities at the hourly time step helps to improve the simulation of floods, especially on Mediterranean catchment areas. Generic values of the additional parameters are proposed to limit the increase in calibration complexity.
23 October 2025 in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
Hydrological climate change impact studies typically rely on hydrological projections generated by hydrological models driven with bias-adjusted climate simulations. Such hydrological projections are influenced by internal climate variability, which can mask the emergence of robust climate trends. To account for internal variability in climate projections, single-model initial-condition large ensembles (SMILEs) can be employed. SMILEs are generated by running a single global/regional climate model many times with slightly perturbed initial conditions. However, it remains challenging to select an appropriate bias adjustment strategy for SMILEs used in hydrological impact studies because of the relative importance of inter-variable dependence and the preservation of both climate variability and the change signal. To facilitate such selection, we here compare different bias adjustment strategies applied to SMILEs and their effect on hydrological impact assessments. Specifically, we investigate how climate and hydrological extremes change for 87 catchments in the Swiss Alps when using (a) univariate vs. bivariate, (b) ensemble vs. individual-member, and (c) change-preserving vs. non-change-preserving bias adjustment methods. To do so, we adjust the biases of a 50-member SMILE with the different adjustment methods and drive a hydrological model to simulate and project high and low flows. Our comparison shows (1) no clear benefits from using bivariate instead of univariate bias adjustment methods when the SMILE already efficiently simulates the dependence between temperature and precipitation and (2) that the choice of using ensemble vs. individual-member and change-preserving vs. non-change-preserving bias adjustments leads to large differences in the values of signal robustness indicators, including temperature, precipitation and streamflow signal-to-noise ratios and streamflow and precipitation time-of-emergence. These influences need to be considered when selecting an appropriate bias adjustment strategy for a given application. Based on our comparison, we generally recommend to apply change-preserving and ensemble bias adjustment methods in future hydrological impact studies using SMILEs. Further research is needed to improve bias adjustment methods that preserve both the signal and the variability of ensemble climate projections.
11 February 2026 in Water Resources Research
Hydrological models are calibrated on specific periods based on how well simulations match streamflow observations by selecting the parameter vector(s) that provide the highest accuracy. This accuracy can decrease significantly during extrapolation to periods not seen during calibration, especially when they are characterized by different climate conditions. Here, we develop a novel calibration objective that relies on the joint calibration of model accuracy and time‐invariance of residuals, hypothesizing that such invariance can improve the temporal generalizability of hydrological models. We test this approach using a hydrological model and 208 catchments in Western Germany. We evaluate it based on (a) the accuracy loss between calibration and evaluation, (b) the compromise between accuracy and residual invariance, (c) the dependence of residuals on variations in forcings, and (d) the instability of parameters between two calibration periods. We find that our approach reduces the loss in accuracy between calibration and extrapolation as compared to calibration approaches solely based on accuracy. Furthermore, our method combined with the Boxcox streamflow transformation weakens the dependence of residuals on variations in the forcing. However, we find that invariant residuals do not necessarily imply improved parameter stability between different calibration periods. Furthermore, the gain in temporal generalizability comes at the cost of a decrease in accuracy, which should be considered based on the application. Our results highlight that the new RESIdual STability (RESIST) calibration objective has the potential to improve the temporal generalizability of hydrological models for climate‐impact studies.