Reviews as one of the premier wheat growing regions in the world. This book is an important work that will help historians and general readers alike understand agricultural production in this region. Robert McCoy Washington State University Whales & Nations: Environmental Diplomacy on the High Seas, 1852–1855 by Kurkpatrick Dorsey foreword by William Cronon University of Washington Press, Seattle and London, 2013. Illustrations, notes, appendix, bibliography, index. 391 pages. $34.95 cloth. Robert Ellis’s The Empty Ocean (2003) is a fairly typical anti-whaling view of humancetacean relations. Ellis, an International Whaling Commission delegate (IWC), sees us progressing from barbarism to enlightenment as we evolve from hunting whales for meat, fluids,and bones to loving them as beings that seem, in Kurk Dorsey’s words, “better than people” (p. 241). This is too tidy. Historical research reveals that exploitation and veneration coexisted for millennia. This should not surprise.Whaling historiography is like a vast, chaotic pod, always threatening to drown its pursuers. Many studies are antiquarian or polemic, but works such as Johan Tonnessen and Arne Johnsen’s The History of Modern Whaling (1982),Margaret Creighton’s Rites and Passages (1995), Lance Davis, Robert Gallman, and Karin Gleiter’s In Pursuit of Leviathan (1997), and Graham Burnett’s The Sounding of the Whale (2012) capture the richness of whaling history.Alas,they are also huge and as dry as a beached whale. Not so with Dorsey’s Whales & Nations,which is nuanced,readable, and takes the often mind-numbing story of international whaling conservation to explain how we modern nations actually managed global nature and why progressive narratives impair historical understanding. Dorsey proceeds chronologically, beginning with two key developments that separated modern whaling from its Melvillian past. After 1880, technological innovations enabled whalers to capture and process the Southern Ocean’s largest baleen whales — humpbacks, seis, fins, and blues — while industrial nations developed new forms of diplomacy to conserve ecologies beyond the control of any nation. Bilateral negotiations evolved into conventions that solidified as the IWC in 1946, but whaling diplomacy was always fraught. Profit concerns, pragmatic responses to rogue whalers, and scientific uncertainties crippled the regulatory process. As Dorsey warns,this book juggles“many moving parts,” but complexity is integral to understanding how nature, economy, and science influenced each other (p. xix). There are no heroes but also few villains. Mostly, we encounter ambiguity. There were whalers who desired conservation but could not curtail harvests, regulators who feared collapse but could not reform governance, and environmentalists who could not admit — perhaps even to themselves — what they really wanted. Contexts also matter, including whale reproduction rates and postwar hunger. And there were twists. Great Britain and Norway dominated diplomacy before 1939, but by 1980 they were out muscled by a welter of tiny countries. The United States was an annoyingly pious non-whaling state until it sided with whaling nations to protect its aboriginal harvesters.The Soviet Union was both breathtakingly corrupt and awe-inspiring in its ability to lie. Most surprisingly, Japan, which is the bête noire of whale lovers, was a remarkably scrupulous and sometimes sympathetic IWC member. Although Dorsey focuses primarily on diplomats and regulators, scientists were crucial actors. From the beginning, negotia- OHQ vol. 115, no. 2 tions between whaling nations reflected that Progressive-era faith in science’s ability to resolve disputes.The gap between what regulators wanted and what scientists knew,however, was literally immeasurable. Technological and theoretical limits and institutional parsimony led to pervasive ignorance about whale biology and ecology, which is why regulators could not, even when they wanted to, lower harvest quotas.Whale science also illuminates broader themes in fisheries history,from Johann Hjort’s connections to industry to a qualification of Carmel Finley’s thesis about Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY) in All the Fish in the Sea (2011). Finley argues that MSY emerged as an American political foil in 1949, but the British had articulated this concept by 1942 .It is hard not to conclude that science was set up to fail and that its inability to deliver aided pretty much everyone but the whales. The history of whaling conservation thus speaks to the problem of protecting nature...