Four nonhalogenated ionic liquids (ILs) based on the same phosphonium cation are investigated in terms of the anion suitability for enhancing the lubricity of a biodegradable oil. For all test conditions, typical for industrial machine components, the lubrication is shown to be governed by nonsacrificial films formed by the physisorption of ionic species on the tribo-surfaces. The anionic structure appears to have an important role in the formation of friction modifying films. The orthoborate ILs exhibit the formation of robust ionic boundary films, resulting in reduced friction and better wear protection. On the contrary, the surface adsorption of phosphinate and phosphate ILs appears to antagonistically disrupt the intrinsic lubrication properties of the biodegradable oil, resulting in high friction and wear. Through additional investigations, it is postulated that the higher dissociation of orthoborate ILs in the biodegradable oil allows the formation of hierarchical and electrostatically overscreened layer structures with long-range order, whereas the ILs with phosphate and phosphinate anions exhibit low dissociation in biodegradable oil, possibly due to the ion pairs being surrounded by a hydrocarbon halo, which presumably results in weak adsorption to form a mixed interfacial layer with no long-range order.
This work shows the impact of reliability influencing factors related to tribology on the monetary saving potential. The gearbox reliability was evaluated using an extended Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) with added connections focusing on the tribological influences on the failure rate. A modified Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA) without accurate reliability connections related to tribology was evaluated for comparison. A 10% improvement in all tribology-related factors in the extended FTA yields 14.96% higher annual failure cost savings, which relates to reduced costs of 22937 €/turbine/year for a 2.5 MW reference turbine. The extended FMEA estimates the saving potential to be 4.99%. The study demonstrates the importance of integrating tribology expertise and cooperation between park owners, manufacturers, suppliers, and academia. Our results demonstrate that even marginal tribological improvements significantly increase wind turbine reliability and monetary savings confirming that tribology, despite being overlooked, is a powerful reliability enhancement tool.