A robust and scalable synthetic platform that provides broad access to thietane-based building blocks is disclosed, covering three oxidation states of sulfur, S(II), S(IV), and S(VI). Starting from readily available thietan-3-one or epithiochlorohydrin, a diverse series of 3-substituted and 3,3-disubstituted thietanes were prepared, including carboxylic acids, primary and secondary amines, alcohols, hydrazines, alkyl halides, sulfonyl halides, etc. The synthetic utility of these fragments was illustrated by the synthesis of thietane-based analogs of a marketed N-acyl sulfonamide drug. Furthermore, a systematic study of the physicochemical properties of the new thietane building blocks was performed in direct comparison with oxetane, azetidine, and cyclobutane analogs. The pKa data for amines and carboxylic acids, along with LogD measurements for model benzamides and anilides, revealed clear structure-property trends depending on the oxidation state of the sulfur atom. While S (II) thietane derivatives remained close to cyclobutane in terms of lipophilicity, S (IV) and S (VI) counterparts were markedly less lipophilic and more acidic/less basic as compared to other model derivatives, even surpassing oxetane in polarity. These findings support the concept of thietane as a versatile “three-in-one” fragment, which sulfur oxidation state can be used to finely modulate ionization state and lipophilicity, enabling the rational design of sp³-rich, polarity-tuned building blocks for modern drug discovery.