Estimating progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival superiority during clinical trials of multiple myeloma (MM) has become increasingly challenging as novel therapeutics have improved patient outcomes. Thus, it is imperative to identify earlier end point surrogates that are predictive of long-term clinical benefit. Minimal residual disease (MRD)-negativity is a common intermediate end point that has shown prognostic value for clinical benefit in MM. This meta-analysis was based on the US Food and Drug Administration guidance for considerations for a meta-analysis of MRD as a clinical end point and evaluates MRD-negativity as an early end point reasonably likely to predict long-term clinical benefit. Eligible studies were phase 2 or 3 randomized controlled clinical trials measuring MRD-negativity as an end point in patients with MM, with follow-up of ≥6 months following an a priori–defined time point of 12 ± 3 months after randomization. Eight newly diagnosed MM studies evaluating 4907 patients were included. Trial-level associations between MRD-negativity and PFS were R2WLSiv, 0.67 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.43-0.91) and R2copula 0.84 (0.64 to >0.99) at the 12-month time point. The individual-level association between 12-month MRD-negativity and PFS resulted in a global odds ratio (OR) of 4.02 (95% CI, 2.57-5.46). For relapse/refractory MM, there were 4 studies included, and the individual-level association between 12-month MRD-negativity and PFS resulted in a global OR of 7.67 (4.24-11.10). A clinical trial demonstrating a treatment effect on MRD is reasonably likely to eventually demonstrate a treatment effect on PFS, suggesting that MRD may be an early clinical end point reasonably likely to predict clinical benefit in MM, that may be used to support accelerated approval and thereby, expedite the availability of new drugs to patients with MM.
OGon behalf of the International Independent Team for Endpoint Approval of Myeloma Minimal Residual Disease (i2TEAMM) Group
on behalf of the International Independent Team for Endpoint Approval of Myeloma Minimal Residual Disease (i2TEAMM) Group
+20
PURPOSE: Newly approved drugs and combinations treating multiple myeloma (MM) have resulted in substantial improvements in patients' survival. To deliver rapid access to newer therapies, an earlier end point to expedite clinical trials is needed. Our objective was to evaluate the minimal residual disease–negative complete response (MRD-CR) as an intermediate end point for progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) in newly diagnosed (ND) transplant-eligible (NDTE) patients, ND transplant-ineligible (NDTinE) patients, and patients with relapsed/refractory (RR) MM. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Individual patient data from 20 randomized multicenter trials were collected. Eleven studies (4,773 patients) with sufficient data were analyzed to evaluate whether 9- or 12-month MRD-CR classified at a 10 –5 threshold could be reasonably likely to predict the clinical benefit of new agents regarding PFS and OS. Global odds ratio (OR) was estimated using the bivariate Plackett Copula model. Supportive evaluation included correlations of the treatment effects on MRD-CR end points and PFS/OS, evaluated by both linear regression ( R2weighted least squared ) and Copula ( R2Copula ) models. RESULTS: The analysis demonstrated that both 9- and 12-month MRD-CR strongly correlated with PFS at patient level in NDTE patients, NDTinE patients, and patients with RRMM. Global ORs ranged from 3.06 to 16.24, all with 95% CIs excluding 1.0. Encouraging trial-level correlations ( R2 , 0.61-0.70) were observed by pooling three populations and were stronger ( R2 , 0.67-0.78) in the ND population. Similar results were observed for OS. CONCLUSION: Our findings provided the support for use of MRD-CR classified at a 10 –5 threshold at either 9 or 12 months after starting of the treatment, as an intermediate end point to support accelerated approvals, in future trials in NDTE patients, NDTinE patients, and patients with RRMM.
Talquetamab, a G protein–coupled receptor class C group 5 member D–targeting bispecific antibody for relapsed/refractory multiple myeloma (R/R MM), plus daratumumab, may lead to deeper and more durable responses than either therapy alone. In the phase 1b TRIMM-2 study, patients with R/R MM (at least 3 previous lines of therapy or double refractory to a proteasome inhibitor and an immunomodulatory drug) received subcutaneous talquetamab 0.4 mg/kg weekly (QW; “QW cohort”) or 0.8 mg/kg every other week (Q2W cohort) plus daratumumab 1800 mg per the approved schedule. The primary end point was safety. Secondary end points included overall response and duration of response. Progression-free survival was an exploratory end point. Sixty-five patients (median 5 previous lines of therapy; 61.5% triple-class refractory; 24.6% bispecific antibody exposed) received talquetamab plus daratumumab (QW, n = 14; Q2W, n = 51; median follow-up of 18.6 months). Most common adverse events were oral events, skin events, cytokine release syndrome, and infections. Grade 3 or 4 events occurred in 81.5%. Two patients had dose-limiting toxicities, both in the Q2W cohort (grade 3 stomatitis/oral mucositis, and grade 3 maculopapular rash). Responses occurred in 71.4% (QW cohort) and 82.4% (Q2W cohort) of patients. Median progression-free survival was 23.3 and 21.2 months, respectively, in each cohort. Pharmacodynamic results suggest the immunomodulatory action of daratumumab contributes to a conducive environment for talquetamab by reducing immunosuppressive cells. Talquetamab plus daratumumab demonstrated promising efficacy outcomes in patients with heavily pretreated disease, with a safety profile consistent with each agent as monotherapy. This trial was registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as #NCT04108195.
10 June 2020 in Statistical Methods in Medical Research
Clinical trials in oncology often involve the statistical analysis of time-to-event data such as progression-free survival or overall survival to determine the benefit of a treatment or therapy. The log-rank test is commonly used to compare time-to-event data from two groups. The log-rank test is especially powerful when the two groups have proportional hazards. However, survival curves encountered in oncology studies that differ from one another do not always differ by having proportional hazards; in such instances, the log-rank test loses power, and the survival curves are said to have “non-proportional hazards”. This non-proportional hazards situation occurs for immunotherapies in oncology; immunotherapies often have a delayed treatment effect when compared to chemotherapy or radiation therapy. To correctly identify and deliver efficacious treatments to patients, it is important in oncology studies to have available a statistical test that can detect the difference in survival curves even in a non-proportional hazards situation such as one caused by delayed treatment effect. An attempt to address this need was the “max-combo” test, which was originally described only for a single analysis timepoint; this article generalizes that test to preserve type I error when there are one or more interim analyses, enabling efficacious treatments to be identified and made available to patients more rapidly.
Teclistamab is the first approved B-cell maturation antigen × CD3 bispecific antibody with weight-based dosing for triple-class–exposed relapsed/refractory multiple myeloma (RRMM). We evaluated the safety and efficacy of teclistamab combined with daratumumab in the phase 1b TRIMM-2 study. Eligible patients had RRMM (≥3 previous lines of therapy [pLOT] or with disease double-refractory to a proteasome inhibitor and immunomodulatory drug); anti-CD38 exposure was permitted. Patients received subcutaneous daratumumab per approved schedule plus weight-based or fixed-dose subcutaneous teclistamab. The primary end point was safety; secondary end points included overall response rate (ORR) and duration of response (DOR). Progression-free survival (PFS) was exploratory. Sixty-one patients received weight-based, recommended phase 2 doses (RP2D; teclistamab 1.5 mg/kg weekly or 3.0 mg/kg every other week); median number of pLOTs was 5 (range, 1-14). Median follow-up was 12.0 months. Common treatment-emergent adverse events (TEAEs) included infections, cytokine release syndrome, neutropenia, and anemia; grade 3/4 TEAEs occurred in 93.4%; 7 died of TEAEs. Any-grade infections occurred in 82.0% (grade 3/4 [maximum toxicity], 45.9%; grade 5, 8.2%). No dose-limiting toxicities occurred. ORR was 68.9% (complete response or better, 44.3%); median DOR was not reached. Median PFS was 26.3 months. A cohort exploring fixed-dose teclistamab (100-300 mg) ended prematurely after a safety signal for fatal infections was identified; out of an abundance of caution, all patients were switched to weight-based dosing. In conclusion, the fully immune-based combination of weight-based RP2D teclistamab plus daratumumab demonstrated deep and durable responses, with a well-characterized safety profile. Results highlight the importance of infection management, including early immunoglobulin replacement. This trial was registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as NCT04108195.
Purpose: We designed mathematical models to describe and quantify the mechanisms and dynamics of minimal residual disease (MRD) in order to better understand these MRD dynamics; inform future treatment design, including when to stop or change treatment; and extrapolate from current progression-free survival (PFS) times to predict future PFS curves. Experimental Design: This study aims to model individual sequential MRD data from phase III clinical trials (MAIA, CASTOR, and POLLUX) using previously developed mathematical models, which will be modified as needed to accurately reflect the actual MRD data. These models will then be used to project PFS curves into the future. Results: Patients with low MRD values either showed rapid disease regrowth, or the MRD values remained low for a prolonged period. Treatment seemed to be most effective in terms of cell kill within the first 6 to 12 months. Regrowth rates were correlated with estimated initial residual disease, particularly in MRD-negative patients. Three-year model extrapolations of PFS were closely comparable with clinical trial data. Conclusions: This model could provide early prediction of PFS outcomes, which otherwise takes lengthy periods of time to observe in clinical trials. Patients showing rapid rebound from low MRD values may benefit from adding another treatment before reaching progressive disease. The MRD analyses and results presented, such as the results about efficacy occurring early in the first 6 to 12 months, may help guide the development and selection of optimal regimens. Longer follow-up periods and application to other trials and datasets are required to substantiate these findings.