Several two-dimensional dissolution rate models for the needle-like compound β l-glutamic acid (BLGA) in water are obtained by first conducting a series of lab-scale experiments and then applying the maximum likelihood parameter estimation technique within a population balance framework. Among these models, a reasonable choice consists of expressions for the dissolution rates along both particles dimensions that are linear in the driving force and yield a constant value of 12 for the ratio of the dissolution rate along the length of the needles to that along their width. The insights gained from this model are applied to discuss the potential of cyclic processes aimed at modifying the size and the shape of BLGA crystals. Furthermore, a model-free feedback control law with the goal to dissolve a given fraction of the overall solid volume initially suspended in a batch system is presented. This controller is tested in a simulation framework making use of the identified dissolution kinetics. It is also validated experimentally by using BLGA and another compound forming needle-like crystals, vanillin. The results demonstrate its effectiveness and its general applicability, making it suitable for the controlled operation of dissolution stages in cyclic size and shape modification processes.
1 December 2019 in Computers & Chemical Engineering
Several operating and control strategies with the purpose of manipulating the size and shape of crystals exhibiting needle-like morphology are presented using an ex situ wet mill as the actuator. A model-based operating policy and different model-free controllers are discussed. These controllers were coupled with an online particle size and shape monitoring tool. First, the attainable region in the size and shape space for a wet milling operation was evaluated in a simulation framework using a multidimensional population balance model describing the breakage phenomenon. Second, the operating and control strategies were tested experimentally in a lab-scale setup using two different milling configurations and two different compounds, namely, β l-glutamic acid and γ d-mannitol. The goal of the experiments was to drive various seed populations of the two compounds to several target average lengths in the size and shape space. It was observed that the model-based operating policy, run without any feedback action, was not able to achieve this goal for arbitrary seed populations. The model-free controllers incorporating feedback were able to do so without relying on any multidimensional breakage model. These controllers enable the robust operation of wet milling stages in complex crystal size and shape modification processes.
Two feedback control approaches for influencing the evolution of the average particle dimensions of populations of needle-like crystals in growth-dominated batch cooling crystallization processes are proposed. The first strategy is a path following control (PFC) approach which does not need access to kinetic models for crystal growth. The second approach consists of a considerably more complex nonlinear model predictive controller (NMPC) that requires the availability of multidimensional crystal growth rate models. The main focus lies in analyzing the effectiveness of these two controllers with respect to successfully operating the considered process, bearing in mind the differing requirements regarding the availability of kinetic models. To this end, both control strategies were coupled with a process simulation framework that features a detailed measurement model emulating the behavior of an existing monitoring device for the evolution of the particle size and shape distribution. It is demonstrated how both controllers can identify the attainable region for the average particle dimensions of a given seed population, and also reach an arbitrary target size and shape within the interior of this region. A performance benefit from operating the more complex NMPC was not observed, which renders the PFC approach suitable and sufficient for the considered application.
The experimental validation of a model-free path following control (PFC) scheme to manipulate the size and shape evolution of needle-like crystals in a seeded, growth-dominated batch cooling crystallization process is presented. To this aim, constant supersaturation control (CSC) and PFC experiments were performed on the needle-shaped compound β l-glutamic acid. First, the feedback controllers were coupled with an online size and shape monitoring tool. Second, attainable regions for the average particle dimensions of two different seed populations were determined experimentally using the CSC strategy, which enabled selecting reasonable targets in the size and shape space for the PFC experiments. Then, PFC experiments were performed to guide the populations of seed crystals to certain targets within the attainable region exhibiting different average sizes and shapes. The PFC strategy was able to successfully and repeatedly complete this task, thereby operating in a model-free fashion in the sense of not requiring multidimensional crystal growth rate models. The experimental validation underlines the effectiveness and the robustness of this feedback control scheme for the considered process.