Yaroslav Kotylko

Yaroslav Kotylko

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Yaroslav Kotylko

State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
30 June 2025 in Public Administration and Regional Development
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
YKYaroslav Kotylko
Yaroslav Kotylko
The aim of the article is a comprehensive study of the system of alternative (non-military) service in Finland, its legal regulation, appointment procedures, features of passage and forms of performance of duty in case of emergency situations and mobilization. Particular attention is paid to comparison with European standards on the implementation of the right to conscientious objection to military service. The study uses Finnish legislation, in particular the Law on Alternative Service (Siviilipalveluslaki 1446/2007), by-laws, official materials of the Alternative Service Center, as well as data from the official website of Siviilipalveluskeskus. The methodological basis of the study is comparative legal, formal legal and system-analytical methods. The article establishes that the alternative service system in Finland is clearly regulated and institutionally supported. It includes a basic training period, community service, additional service, as well as special forms of service in emergency situations and during mobilization. The mechanisms for implementing the obligation are determined, the role of the Alternative Service Center as the main administrative body, the procedure for dismissal, deferment, disciplinary liability and registration of persons obliged to serve. The Finnish model of alternative service is an example of an effective balance between the constitutional right of an individual to freedom of conscience and the general obligation to protect the state. The system allows for the realization of the right to refuse military service by participating in civilian activities that are of a socially beneficial nature, while maintaining the state's readiness to act in times of crisis and emergency. Finland's experience in aspects of legal regulation, social security, financing and control over the completion of alternative service is important for Ukraine, which is in the process of reforming its own alternative service system during the Russian-Ukrainian war.

28 April 2022 in Scientific Journal of Polonia University
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
YKYaroslav Kotylko
Yaroslav Kotylko
AIAlexander Ignatenko
Alexander Ignatenko
The article considers the issue of the creation and registration of religious organizations and the acquisition of the status of a legal entity. The main problems faced by religious organizations in the process of state recognition are considered. The methods of state registration of religious organizations depending on their type are described, the powers of regional and central executive bodies regarding the legal recognition of religious organizations are outlined. Proposals have been made to amend the current legislation to create a transparent process for registering religious organizations. The article defines religious organizations in Ukraine such as religious communities, centers, administrations, monasteries, church unions, missions, theological educational institutions, organizations, and associations. As the registration procedure of religious organizations has two stages of registration in Ukraine, the article describes in detail each of the stages of state registration of religious organizations. The article describes the state benefits that religious organizations in Ukraine can receive after obtaining the status of a legal entity.

30 September 2025 in Public Administration and Regional Development
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
YKYaroslav Kotylko
Yaroslav Kotylko
This article presents a comprehensive study of the system of alternative (non-military) service in the Republic of China (Taiwan), with a particular focus on its specialized forms-namely, the R&D Substitute Service and the Industry Training Substitute Service. The author examines the legal and organizational mechanisms underlying these forms of service, including the procedures for competitive selection of institutions authorized to host conscripts, the criteria for evaluating operational plans and scientific achievements, and the system of quota allocation. Special attention is given to the analysis of socio-legal guarantees for individuals undergoing alternative service in Taiwan, particularly regarding job retention, preservation of academic status, access to medical care, financial assistance, and social security. The article also explores the legal grounds for service suspension, mechanisms for changing the place of service, and the duties imposed on conscripts, including the oath of allegiance and confidentiality obligations. As part of a comparative analysis, the study examines key aspects of the Ukrainian model of alternative service, including the procedure for its implementation, labor guarantees, financial provisions, and liability for non-compliance. The findings reveal the absence of uniform standards for remuneration in Ukraine, leading to substantial disparities between military personnel and individuals performing alternative service under fixed-term labor contracts. Several systemic issues are identified, including the lack of clear procedures for transferring conscripts between institutions, insufficient social protection, the absence of compensation mechanisms for injury or illness, and inadequate sanctions for evasion of service. The results of the study confirm the advanced institutional and legal framework of Taiwan’s alternative service system, which may serve as an effective model for Ukraine. Based on this, the article offers practical recommendations for integrating selected elements of the Taiwanese system into Ukrainian legislation, taking into account national legal, cultural, and security contexts-particularly in the context of the ongoing war and the urgent need to balance defense imperatives with the protection of human rights.

23 June 2025 in OSF Preprints
Verified
Preprint
Open access
YKYaroslav Kotylko
Yaroslav Kotylko
The article is devoted to the analysis of the legal and organizational aspects of alternative (non-military) service in the Republic of Korea. Particular attention is paid to the process of its formation, legal evolution and the role of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Korea in recognizing the right of citizens to conscientious objection to military service. The author considers the mechanisms for implementing alternative service, including the procedure for applying, the selection criteria of the Alternative Service Commission, the conditions of service and financial support for persons who have chosen this type of military service.The article also analyzes the features of the legal regulation of alternative service, in particular its connection with the national security system. The issues of the social status of alternative service workers, their rights and obligations, as well as restrictions, in particular regarding political activity, are considered. An important aspect of the study is the comparative analysis of alternative service in South Korea and Ukraine, which allows identifying common features and key differences in approaches to regulating this institution.The author pays attention to international standards for the protection of human rights, recommendations of international organizations, such as the UN and the Venice Commission, regarding alternative service and its compliance with the principle of freedom of conscience. The practice of verifying the motives of conscientious objectors, the possibility of its improvement, as well as the issue of excessive interference in the private lives of applicants are separately considered.The experience of South Korea in the aspects of legal regulation, social security, financing and control over the completion of alternative service is important for Ukraine, which is in the process of reforming its own alternative service system during the Russian-Ukrainian war. The introduction of transparent procedures for recognizing conscientious objectors, determining reasonable criteria for verifying motives, regulating issues of social and material security are key tasks for further improving the relevant legislation.

1 January 2023 in Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Public Administration
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
YKYaroslav Kotylko
Yaroslav Kotylko
ARAnatoliy Rachynskyi
Anatoliy Rachynskyi
В с т у п . Актуальність. Досліджено вплив релігійних організацій у контексті російсько-української війни та проаналізовано їхню діяльність у протистоянні російській агресії. Ураховуючи значущість суспільно-релігійних відносин у кризових ситуаціях, розкрито нові аспекти діяльності релігійних організацій в Україні. Метою статті є аналіз діяльності релігійних організацій на території України під час військової агресії Російської Федерації. Завдання включають аналіз суспільно-релігійних відносин у контексті війни, дослідження гуманітарної та миротворчої діяльності релігійних організацій, а також пропозиції щодо формування державної політики у сфері суспільно-релігійних відносин. Об'єктом дослідження є діяльність релігійних організацій на території України в умовах військової агресії Російської Федерації проти України. Дослідження зосереджується на впливі та ролі релігійних організацій у протистоянні російській окупації, зокрема на аналізі суспільно-релігійних відносин під час російсько-української війни. У контексті дослідження розглянуто два основних напрями діяльності релігійних організацій – гуманітарний та миротворчий. Основним завданням є вивчення впливу цих організацій на громадський опір агресору, а також формування пропозицій щодо розвитку механізмів державної політики у сфері суспільно-релігійних відносин. М е т о д и . Використано аналітичний підхід, структурний аналіз та емпіричні методи. Аналітичний підхід застосовується для аналізу суспільно-релігійних відносин та їх впливу на ситуацію в умовах військової агресії. Структурний аналіз дає змогу дослідити гуманітарну та миротворчу діяльність релігійних організацій. Емпіричні методи використовуються для збирання та аналізу фактичних даних, що стосуються ролі релігійних організацій у протистоянні агресору. Метод кейс-стаді, або метод конкретних ситуацій, було використано для дослідження конкретних випадків успішної діяльності релігійних організацій у кризових ситуаціях. Р е з у л ь т а т и . Аналізуючи діяльність релігійних організацій, виявлено, що вони відіграють важливу роль у громадському опорі агресору. Релігійні організації активно займаються гуманітарною та миротворчою діяльністю, забезпечуючи допомогу внутрішньо переміщеним особам, евакуйованим громадянам, а також інформуючи світ про російську агресію. В и с н о в к и . Дослідження підтверджує значущість громадської мобілізації та гуманітарної діяльності релігійних організацій у кризових ситуаціях. Для досягнення успішних результатів у боротьбі з ворогом держава повинна сприяти розвитку релігійної діяльності та забезпечити умови для їхньої гуманітарної та миротворчої роботи.

23 June 2025 in OSF Preprints
Verified
Preprint
Open access
YKYaroslav Kotylko
Yaroslav Kotylko
This article presents a comprehensive study of the institution of alternative (non-military) service in the Hellenic Republic—one of the few European countries where the right to conscientious objection to military service is explicitly enshrined at the constitutional level. The paper explores the historical and legal development of this institution, including the evolution of legislative regulation from 1977 to the present, and analyzes key legal acts, such as Law No. 3421/2005, as well as presidential decrees and ministerial decisions specifying the procedures for performing alternative service.Particular attention is paid to the case law of the Greek Council of State (ΣτΕ), which has played a central role in shaping the current understanding of the legal nature of alternative service and in defining the criteria under which a person may be recognized as a conscientious objector. The article also considers the practice of the European Court of Human Rights (notably the case “Tsirlis and Kouloumbas v. Greece”), the European Committee of Social Rights, and recommendations of theCouncil of Europe institutions regarding the compatibility of the Greek model with international human rights standards.The study highlights major challenges in the functioning of alternative service: excessive duration compared to compulsory military service, inadequate social protection, discriminatory legal provisions that exclude certain categories of citizens from accessing this right, and the possibility of forced return to military service in case of non-compliance. Special attention is given to the problematic nature of the suspension of alternative service during wartime and its compatibility with the principle of freedom of conscience.Based on a systemic analysis of the Greek experience, the article formulates a set of recommendations for Ukraine, which is currently undergoing reform of its own alternative service system. It outlines how the Greek case can serve as both a positive and cautionary example in the broader context of ensuring constitutional rights and fulfilling international human rights obligations.