Conferring alloantigen-specificity to ex vivo expanded CD4+CD25+Foxp3+ Tregs increases their capacity to counteract effector alloimmune responses following adoptive transfer into transplant recipients. Three strategies are currently undergoing clinical development, which involve: 1) expanding Tregs in the presence of donor B cells (donor alloantigen-reactive (DAR-Tregs)); 2) culturing Tregs with donor cells in the presence of co-stimulation blockade (CSB-Tregs); and 3) transducing Tregs with an HLA-A2-specific chimeric antigen receptor (CAR-Tregs). Our goal here was to assess the relative potency of each of these manufactured Treg products both in vitro and in vivo. As compared to polyclonal Tregs, all 3 manufacture strategies increased the precursor frequency of alloreactive Tregs, and this was proportional to the overall in vitro immunosuppressive properties of the cell products. Accordingly, CAR-Tregs, which contained the highest frequency of donor-reactive Tregs, exhibited the strongest suppressive effects on a cell-per-cell basis. Similarly, in an in vivo mouse model of GvHD, infusion of CAR-Tregs conferred a significantly longer recipient survival than any other Treg product. Our results highlighting the alloantigen-reactivity and associated immunosuppressive properties of different manufactured Treg products have implications for the mechanistic interpretation of currently ongoing clinical trials in transplantation.