This paper summarizes the results of a research project analyzing communication about global warming among those in the fields of science, politics, and the media in Germany between 1975 and 1995. The methodology of discourse analysis has been applied to investigate the changing perceptions of climate change over time and the ways in which it became an important issue on Germany's political agenda. The first part of the paper will briefly introduce the underlying theoretical assumptions and explain the multiple steps by which data covering a period of two decades have been collected and analyzed. In the second part, the paper will provide the reader with the main research results, indicating the usefulness of distinguishing among the separate discourses on climate change in science, politics, and the mass media. The results suggest that there are specific discourse dynamics common to each of the three spheres, as well as some important disparities among them. These findings will be illustrated by a selection of examples typical of the samples analyzed. Finally, the third part of the paper will discuss the broader theoretical and practical implications of these results, which suggest that modern societies must cope not only with environmental risks but also with the risks inherent in communication.
Science communication, whether internally or to the general public depends on trust, both trust in the source and trust in the medium of communication. With the new 'ecology of communication' this trust is endangered. On the one hand the very term of science communication has been captured by many different actors (e.g., governments, PR experts, universities and research institutions, science journalists, and bloggers) apart from scientists themselves to whom science communication means different things and whose communication is tainted by special interests. Some of these actors are probably more trusted by the general public than others. On the other hand, the channels that are used to communicate science are also not trusted equally. Particularly the widespread use of social media raises doubts about the credibility of the communication spread through them.
Zusammenfassung: Die Wissenschaftskritik richtet sich auf die Forschung selbst und wird in Form von Kontrollen institutionalisiert. Der Frage, ob sich damit ein neues Arrangement zwischen Wissenschaft und Gesellschaft ankündigt, wird anhand der Analyse zweier Prozesse nachgegangen: der Verwissenschaftlichung und damit der Delegitimierung gesellschaftlicher Werte und Institutionen und der gegenläufigen Politisierung von Wissenschaft. Die Wissenschaft scheint ethischen Bezügen nicht entrinnen zu können, auch dann nicht, wenn sie sie szientistisch zu begründen sucht. So bleibt der Konflikt unaufgelöst.