4 May 2019 in Australian Archaeology
Skeletal evidence of health during the Holocene in south-eastern Australia has contributed to discussions on the mobility and population size of peoples living on the Murray River. One argument is that peoples living on the Murray River experienced poor health evidenced by high frequencies of physiological stress indicators in human remains (enamel hypoplasia, cribra orbitalia, and Harris lines). However, this is not the only explanation for the high frequencies of stress indicators found in these human remains. An alternative but not mutually exclusive interpretation is that individuals with many stress markers such as enamel hypoplasia are the survivors of childhood stressors, and therefore reflect the ability of an individual to overcome periods of physiological stress. The paradoxical interpretation that better health can make for worse skeletons is part of the osteological paradox. These contradictory interpretations can be tested through the analysis of enamel hypoplasia (EH) at Roonka, a large Aboriginal burial site on the Murray River (8,000–200 BP). Survival analysis identifies the mortality consequences of having an enamel defect. This type of analysis allows for a better understanding of the risk associated with having a defect, or multiple defects, in relation to age at death. Age at death and the number of defects was recorded for 130 individuals. The results suggest that, while enamel defects are prevalent among the human remains from Roonka, EH is not associated with an increased risk of death. Results demonstrate that aspects of the osteological paradox are at play in interpretations of enamel defects at Roonka. These results provide evidence that caution is needed when using EH frequency data to argue about past population health.
22 January 2024 in Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences
Archaeological strontium isotope investigations of the movement of peoples and animals rely on different methods to characterize a “local” strontium range. In geologically homogenous regions or regions where the creation of isoscapes using proxies is hampered, statistical methods are useful for identifying individuals likely to be local or non-local. We demonstrate how a multi-method approach can be used to evaluate local strontium isotope ranges in Bahrain, an archipelago in the Arabian Gulf. Combining the enamel samples analyzed for this paper (62 human and domesticate herbivore individuals) with previously published faunal 87Sr/86Sr values from Bahrain (20 domesticated herbivores), we found that different statistical methods identified different numbers of individuals as local and were predicated on different assumptions about the distribution of the data. Compared to the standard approach using 2σ of the sample mean, the statistical approaches used in this manuscript identified more potential non-local or securely non-local individuals. Between 18.5 and 44.4% of the non-human animals were identified as non-local, indicating the trade of animals and why using faunal (herbivore) samples alone to characterize a local range is problematic in trading centers. The identification of between 13.7 and 32.9% of the humans as non-local is consistent with other studies of movement in archaeological populations of the Gulf and makes sense given the prominent role of trade in Bahrain from the Early Dilmun to Islamic periods. We argue that statistical approaches to identifying probable non-locals can be used where detailed isoscape data are hard to obtain, but that such results need to be evaluated within the specific archaeological context.
6 May 2026 in Royal Society Open Science
As argued for the Black Death, catastrophes are rarely unicausal and identifying them needs consideration of context. Scholars have focused on the Plague of Justinian, debating whether mass interments reflect its impact. We argue that, even when interments align chronologically, determining the nature of the crisis requires multiple lines of evidence. The DS3 moundfield on Bahrain is a multi-period site with 290 tombs. Recent radiocarbon dating of three tombs places them in the Sasanian period. Bayesian analysis suggests these tombs were used during the early years of the Justinianic plague. The tombs are anomalous. Multiple interments existed in this era, but these tombs have very large numbers of dead. A minimum of 149 people were in mound 73 (tomb 18) and 86 people in mound 83 (tomb 5) mainly non-adults. These are some of the largest collective interments linked to the Justinianic period. This paper tests whether these interments reflect a catastrophic event using dating, burial practices, demography and palaeopathology. We conclude that they represent catastrophic mortality during the pandemic’s onset, but they were not caused by Yersinia pestis. The findings reinforce the observation that multiple hazards create the conditions for pathogen spread, but they provide possibilities for more than one organism.
22 June 2026 in International Journal of Heritage Studies
10 February 2026 in Journal of Pacific Archaeology
Marine paleoclimate records for the last 1,000 years are scarce in the southwest Pacific, limiting our understanding of complex environmental changes that may have affected Māori seascapes and fisheries. We seek to begin filling this knowledge gap by studying stable oxygen (δ18O) and carbon (δ13C) isotopes in archaeological and modern otoliths from tāmure (Australasian snapper, Chrysophrys auratus), which provide information about water temperature, salinity, and fish diet and metabolism. Our results show that fourteenth and fifteenth century tāmure otoliths recorded environmental conditions that are comparable to twentieth century temperatures, with some evidence for anomalously warmer seas and/or higher precipitation during the fifteenth century. These findings are concordant with previous reconstructions of terrestrial climatic conditions in northern Aotearoa and of central west Pacific Ocean sea surface temperatures, providing additional evidence that Māori experienced a warm climatic period during their first centuries of habitation and fishing in the North Island.
1 July 2026 in Royal Society Open Science
Social structure plays a key role in shaping ecological and evolutionary dynamics in group-living animals, yet its influence on genetic connectivity and foraging ecology remains understudied in wide-ranging marine predators. Here, we used mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequencing and stable isotopes of carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) to evaluate matrilineal and ecological connectivity in a highly mobile, socially complex marine predator, the false killer whale (Pseudorca crassidens). We analysed skin samples (n = 164) collected from three different Southern Hemisphere regions: a stranding event in Falkland Islands (nS = 19), biopsied animals from Australia (nB = 7) and a combination of stranded and biopsied animals from Aotearoa New Zealand (nS = 52, nB = 86). We designated sets of samples as separate partitions (n = 8) based on sampling region, sample type and/or time of sampling. Haplotype number and diversity were low within sample partitions representing (known or presumed) social clusters of false killer whales, with significant overall and pairwise differentiation (FST = 0.89, p ≤ 0.01; ΦST = 0.94, p < 0.01), consistent with distinct matrilineal groups. These social clusters each had narrow isotopic niche regions (less than 2‰2) with little or no overlap between them (less than 5%), suggesting ecological separation. These findings highlight the value of complementary datasets in understanding both genetic and ecological divergence in wide-ranging social mammals.