Whether in ant–aphid mutualism the ants exert evolutionary selection pressure on aphid morphology has not yet been fully tested. Here, we tested whether the long proboscises of Stomaphis yanonis (Aphididae Lachninae) aphids confer an advantage in preventing predation by the tending ants. Specifically, we tested the hypothesis that aphids with a shorter proboscis would excrete less honeydew, making them more likely to be preyed upon by ants. Our results showed that aphid individuals with a shorter proboscis took up less phloem sap and excreted less honeydew than individuals with a longer proboscis. In addition, among aphids with a similar body size, those with a shorter proboscis were more susceptible to predation by ants than those with a longer proboscis. These results suggest that predation by tending ants, by exerting selection pressure on aphid proboscis morphology, has caused the aphids to evolve longer proboscises.
Many ant-aphid interactions illustrate the concept of a mutually beneficial association between two organisms: aphids provide ants with honeydew; in return, ants defend aphids from enemies. However, ants also often prey on the aphids they attend, and we do not know if the predation pressure causes any adaptations on the side of aphids. The aphid Stomaphis japonica has an obligate mutualistic association with Lasius ants. Here, we report evidence of selective predation of less-honeydew secreting Stomaphis aphids by the tending Lasius ants. We show that 1. the aphids are severely preyed on by the ants – up to half of the aphids’ standing population per day. 2. the ants selectively prey on the aphids which do not deliver honeydew when attacked, and 3. the frequency of aphids’ honeydew secretion is heritable. These results suggest selective predation by ants against less-honeydew secreting aphids takes place and it is heritable.