This paper aims to investigate and quantify the turbulence effect on droplet collision efficiency and explore the broadening mechanism of the droplet size distribution (DSD) in cumulus clouds. The sophisticated model employed in this study individually traces droplet motions affected by gravity, droplet disturbance flows, and turbulence in a Lagrangian frame. Direct numerical simulation (DNS) techniques are implemented to resolve the small-scale turbulence. Collision statistics for cloud droplets of radii between 5 and 25 μm at five different turbulence dissipation rates (20–500 cm2 s−3) are computed and compared with pure-gravity cases. The results show that the turbulence enhancement of collision efficiency highly depends on the r ratio (defined as the radius ratio of collected and collector droplets r/ R) but is less sensitive to the size of the collector droplet investigated in this study. Particularly, the enhancement is strongest among comparable-sized collisions, indicating that turbulence can significantly broaden the narrow DSD resulting from condensational growth. Finally, DNS experiments of droplet growth by collision–coalescence in turbulence are performed for the first time in the literature to further illustrate this hypothesis and to monitor the appearance of drizzle in the early rain-formation stage. By comparing the resulting DSDs at different turbulence intensities, it is found that broadening is most pronounced when turbulence is strongest and similar-sized collisions account for 21%–24% of total collisions in turbulent cases compared with only 9% in the gravitational case.
12 May 2021 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres
Several single‐year‐long (2017) simulations with different configurations of the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model over the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the Middle‐East at the convective gray‐zone resolution (9 km) are evaluated in their ability to capture the temporal and spatial distributions of precipitation. Annual rainfall over the Middle‐East is dominated by wintertime precipitation and is mostly initiated by the frontal systems intrusion. WRF at 9 km resolution shows good skill in capturing the synoptic and meso‐scale precipitation distributions. The aerosol‐aware Thompson microphysics scheme outperforms the WRF double moment 6 class microphysics by about 20% in annual mean precipitation over the Middle‐East. Different Planetary Boundary Layer (PBL) physics leads to large differences in the annual rainfall over both the Middle‐East (about 30%) and the UAE (about 45%). The Quasi‐Normal Scale Elimination (QNSE) PBL scheme produces stronger precipitation than the Asymmetrical Convective Model and is in better agreement with observations. This difference is attributed to the former scheme producing a warmer and moister lower‐level atmosphere that builds more substantial instability. Regions of stronger instability also depict decreases in lifting condensation level heights and increases in boundary layer height, suggesting that the boundary layer reaching the cloud base helps to trigger the convection and increase precipitation. Refinement in grid spacing (5 km) marginally improves the summertime precipitation over the Middle‐East but significantly increases the computational cost. Current study also indicates that gray‐zone simulations can perform as good as convection‐permitting simulations by carefully choosing the right model physics packages for the synoptic and meso‐scale precipitation.
31 August 2020 in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
This paper investigates the relative importance of turbulence and aerosol effects on the broadening of the droplet size distribution (DSD) during the early stage of cloud and raindrop formation. A parcel–DNS (direct numerical simulation) hybrid approach is developed to seamlessly simulate the evolution of cloud droplets in an ascending cloud parcel. The results show that turbulence and cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) hygroscopicity are key to the efficient formation of large droplets. The ultragiant aerosols can quickly form embryonic drizzle drops and thus determine the onset time of autoconversion. However, due to their scarcity in natural clouds, their contribution to the total mass of drizzle drops is insignificant. In the meantime, turbulence sustains the formation of large droplets by effectively accelerating the collisions of small droplets. The DSD broadening through turbulent collisions is significant and therefore yields a higher autoconversion rate compared to that in a nonturbulent case. It is argued that the level of autoconversion is heavily determined by turbulence intensity. This paper also presents an in-cloud seeding scenario designed to scrutinize the effect of aerosols in terms of number concentration and size. It is found that seeding more aerosols leads to higher competition for water vapor, reduces the mean droplet radius, and therefore slows down the autoconversion rate. On the other hand, increasing the seeding particle size can buffer such a negative feedback. Despite the fact that the autoconversion rate is prominently altered by turbulence and seeding, bulk variables such as liquid water content (LWC) stays nearly identical among all cases. Additionally, the lowest autoconversion rate is not co-located with the smallest mean droplet radius. The finding indicates that the traditional Kessler-type or Sundqvist-type autoconversion parameterizations, which depend on the LWC or mean radius, cannot capture the drizzle formation process very well. Properties related to the width or the shape of the DSD are also needed, suggesting that the scheme of Berry and Reinhardt (1974) is conceptually better. It is also suggested that a turbulence-dependent relative-dispersion parameter should be considered.
1 February 2016 in Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
The purpose of this paper is to quantify the influence of turbulence in collision statistics by separately studying the impacts of computational domain sizes, eddy dissipation rates (EDRs), and droplet sizes and eventually to develop an accurate parameterization of collision kernels. Direct numerical simulations (DNS) were performed with a relatively wide range of EDRs and Taylor microscale Reynolds numbers . EDR measures the turbulence intensity levels. DNS model studies have simulated homogeneous turbulence in a small domain in the cloud’s adiabatic core. Clouds clearly have much larger scales than current DNS can simulate. For this reason, it is emphasized that obtained from current DNS is fundamentally only a measure of the computational domain size for a given EDR and cannot completely describe the physical properties of cloud turbulence. Results show that the collision statistics are independent of the domain sizes and hence of the computational for droplet sizes no bigger than 25 μ m as long as the droplet separation distance, which is on the order of the Kolmogorov scale in real clouds, is resolved. Instead, they are found to be highly correlated with EDRs and droplet sizes, and this correlation is used to formulate an improved parameterization scheme. The new scheme well represents the turbulent geometric collision kernel with a relative uncertainty of 14%. A comparison between different parameterizations is made, and the formulas proposed here are shown to improve the fit to the collision statistics.
In most previous direct numerical simulation (DNS) studies on droplet growth in turbulence, condensational growth and collisional growth were treated separately. Studies in recent decades have postulated that small-scale turbulence may accelerate droplet collisions when droplets are still small when condensational growth is effective. This implies that both processes should be considered simultaneously to unveil the full history of droplet growth and rain formation. This paper introduces the first direct numerical simulation approach to explicitly study the continuous droplet growth by condensation and collisions inside an adiabatic ascending cloud parcel. Results from the condensation-only, collision-only, and condensation–collision experiments are compared to examine the contribution to the broadening of droplet size distribution (DSD) by the individual process and by the combined processes. Simulations of different turbulent intensities are conducted to investigate the impact of turbulence on each process and on the condensation-induced collisions. The results show that the condensational process promotes the collisions in a turbulent environment and reduces the collisions when in still air, indicating a positive impact of condensation on turbulent collisions. This work suggests the necessity of including both processes simultaneously when studying droplet–turbulence interaction to quantify the turbulence effect on the evolution of cloud droplet spectrum and rain formation.
Cloud microphysical processes occur at the smallest end of scales among cloud-related processes and thus must be parameterized not only in large-scale global circulation models (GCMs) but also in various higher-resolution limited-area models such as cloud-resolving models (CRMs) and large-eddy simulation (LES) models. Instead of giving a comprehensive review of existing microphysical parameterizations that have been developed over the years, this study concentrates purposely on several topics that we believe are understudied but hold great potential for further advancing bulk microphysics parameterizations: multi-moment bulk microphysics parameterizations and the role of the spectral shape of hydrometeor size distributions; discrete vs “continuous” representation of hydrometeor types; turbulence-microphysics interactions including turbulent entrainment-mixing processes and stochastic condensation; theoretical foundations for the mathematical expressions used to describe hydrometeor size distributions and hydrometeor morphology; and approaches for developing bulk microphysics parameterizations. Also presented are the spectral bin scheme and particle-based scheme (especially, super-droplet method) for representing explicit microphysics. Their advantages and disadvantages are elucidated for constructing cloud models with detailed microphysics that are essential to developing processes understanding and bulk microphysics parameterizations. Particle-resolved direct numerical simulation (DNS) models are described as an emerging technique to investigate turbulence-microphysics interactions at the most fundamental level by tracking individual particles and resolving the smallest turbulent eddies in turbulent clouds. Outstanding challenges and future research directions are explored as well.