Flight operations involve shift and night work, long waking hours, crossing time zones, and frequent changes in crew schedules, which can disrupt sleep and circadian rhythms and lead to fatigue and reduced situational awareness during critical phases of flight. In addition to prescribed flight time restrictions, airlines implement fatigue risk management systems to identify hazards in a timely manner. In this study, using chronometric cognitive reaction meters—namely, Complex Reactiometer Drenovac—the performances of four pilots were quantified over a certain period of time. Temporal causal modeling identified causal relations among performance indicators and organizational workload settings, such as duty time, flight time, split duty, duration and number of sectors, aircraft turnaround times, and delays. Scenario simulations confirmed the detected causal relations and enabled the definition of measures to reduce fatigue risk and optimize crew scheduling.