Dinshaw S. Balsara

Dinshaw S. Balsara

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Dinshaw S. Balsara

Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN, USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

26Years (2001-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 March 2004 in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
DBDinshaw S. Balsara
Dinshaw S. Balsara
While working on an adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) scheme for divergence-free magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), Balsara discovered a unique strategy for the reconstruction of divergence-free vector fields. Balsara also showed that for one-dimensional variations in flow and field quantities the reconstruction reduces exactly to the total variation diminishing (TVD) reconstruction. In a previous paper by Balsara the innovations were put to use in studying AMR-MHD. While the other consequences of the invention especially as they pertain to numerical scheme design were mentioned, they were not explored in any detail. In this paper we begin such an exploration. We study the problem of divergence-free numerical MHD and show that the work done so far still has four key unresolved issues. We resolve those issues in this paper. It is shown that the magnetic field can be updated in divergence-free fashion with a formulation that is better than the one in Balsara & Spicer. The problem of reconstructing MHD flow variables with spatially second-order accuracy is also studied. Some ideas from weighted essentially non-oscillatory (WENO) reconstruction, as they apply to numerical MHD, are developed. Genuinely multidimensional reconstruction strategies for numerical MHD are also explored. The other goal of this paper is to show that the same well-designed second-order-accurate schemes can be formulated for more complex geometries such as cylindrical and spherical geometry. Being able to do divergence-free reconstruction in those geometries also resolves the problem of doing AMR in those geometries; the appendices contain detailed formulae for the same. The resulting MHD scheme has been implemented in Balsara's RIEMANN framework for parallel, self-adaptive computational astrophysics. The present work also shows that divergence-free reconstruction and the divergence-free time update can be done for numerical MHD on unstructured meshes. As a result, we establish important analogies between MHD on structured meshes and MHD on unstructured meshes because such analogies can guide the design of MHD schemes and AMR-MHD techniques on unstructured meshes. The present paper also lays out the roadmap for designing MHD schemes for structured and unstructured meshes that have better than second-order accuracy in space and time. All the schemes designed here are shown to be second-order-accurate. We also show that the accuracy does not depend on the quality of the Riemann solver. We have compared the numerical dissipation of the unsplit MHD schemes presented here with the dimensionally split MHD schemes that have been used in the past and found the former to be superior. The dissipation does depend on the Riemann solver, but the dependence becomes weaker as the quality of the interpolation is improved. Several stringent test problems are presented to show that the methods work, including problems involving high-velocity flows in low-plasma-β magnetospheric environments. Similar advances can be made in other fields, such as electromagnetics, radiation MHD, and incompressible flow, that rely on a Stokes-law type of update strategy.

1 January 2014 in Journal of Computational Physics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CMChad D. Meyer
Chad D. Meyer
DBDinshaw S. Balsara
Dinshaw S. Balsara
TATariq Aslam
Tariq Aslam

20 February 2004 in The Astrophysical Journal
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
DBDinshaw S. Balsara
Dinshaw S. Balsara
JKJongsoo Kim
Jongsoo Kim
In recent years, several different strategies have emerged for evolving the magnetic field in numerical MHD. Some of these methods can be classified as divergence-cleaning schemes, where one evolves the magnetic field components just like any other variable in a higher order Godunov scheme. The fact that the magnetic field is divergence-free is imposed post-facto via a divergence-cleaning step. Other schemes for evolving the magnetic field rely on a staggered mesh formulation which is inherently divergence-free. The claim has been made that the two approaches are equivalent. In this paper we cross-compare three divergence-cleaning schemes based on scalar and vector divergence-cleaning and a popular divergence-free scheme. All schemes are applied to the same stringent test problem. Several deficiencies in all the divergence-cleaning schemes become clearly apparent with the scalar divergence-cleaning schemes performing worse than the vector divergence-cleaning scheme. The vector divergence-cleaning scheme also shows some deficiencies relative to the staggered mesh divergence-free scheme. The differences can be explained by realizing that all the divergence-cleaning schemes are based on a Poisson solver which introduces a non-locality into the scheme, though other subtler points of difference are also catalogued. By using several diagnostics that are routinely used in the study of turbulence, it is shown that the differences in the schemes produce measurable differences in physical quantities that are of interest in such studies

10 December 2004 in The Astrophysical Journal
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
DBDinshaw S. Balsara
Dinshaw S. Balsara
JKJongsoo Kim
Jongsoo Kim
MLMordecai‐Mark Mac Low
Mordecai‐Mark Mac Low
GMGrant J. Mathews
Grant J. Mathews
Several lines of evidence suggest that magnetic fields grow rapidly in protogalactic and galactic environments. However, mean field dynamo theory has always suggested that the magnetic fields grow rather slowly, taking of order a Hubble time to reach the observed values. The theoretical difficulties only become worse when the system has a high magnetic Reynolds number, as is the case for galactic and protogalactic environments. The discrepancy can be reconciled if fast processes for amplifying the magnetic field could operate. Following the 2001 work of Balsara and coworkers, we show that an interstellar medium that is dominated by realistic energy input from supernova explosions will naturally become a strongly turbulent medium with large positive and negative values of the kinetic helicity. Even though the medium is driven by compressible motions, the kinetic energy in this high Mach number flow is mainly concentrated in solenoidal rather than compressible motions. These results stem from the interaction of strong shocks with each other and with the interstellar turbulence they self-consistently generate in our model. Moreover, this interaction also generates large kinetic helicities of either sign. The turbulent flow that we model has two other characteristics of a fast dynamo: magnetic energy growth independent of scale and a growth time that is comparable to the eddy turnover time. This linear phase of growth permits the field to grow rapidly until the magnetic energy reaches about 1% of the kinetic energy. At that stage, other astrophysical processes for producing magnetic fields can take over. Energetics, power spectra, statistics, and structures of the turbulent flow are studied here. Shock-turbulence interaction is shown to be a very general mechanism for helicity generation and magnetic field amplification, with applicability to damped Lyα systems, protogalaxies, the Galaxy, starburst galaxies, the intracluster medium, and molecular clouds.

6 September 2018 in International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MDMichael Dumbser
Michael Dumbser
DBD.S. Balsara
D.S. Balsara
MTM. Tavelli
M. Tavelli
FFFrancesco Fambri
Francesco Fambri
Summary: In this paper, we present a novel pressure‐based semi‐implicit finite volume solver for the equations of compressible ideal, viscous, and resistive magnetohydrodynamics (MHD). The new method is conservative for mass, momentum, and total energy, and in multiple space dimensions, it is constructed in such a way as to respect the divergence‐free condition of the magnetic field exactly, also in the presence of resistive effects. This is possible via the use of multidimensional Riemann solvers on an appropriately staggered grid for the time evolution of the magnetic field and a double curl formulation of the resistive terms. The new semi‐implicit method for the MHD equations proposed here discretizes the nonlinear convective terms as well as the time evolution of the magnetic field explicitly, whereas all terms related to the pressure in the momentum equation and the total energy equation are discretized implicitly, making again use of a properly staggered grid for pressure and velocity. Inserting the discrete momentum equation into the discrete energy equation then yields a mildly nonlinear symmetric and positive definite algebraic system for the pressure as the only unknown, which can be efficiently solved with the (nested) Newton method of Casulli et al. The pressure system becomes linear when the specific internal energy is a linear function of the pressure. The time step of the scheme is restricted by a CFL condition based only on the fluid velocity and the Alfvén wave speed and is not based on the speed of the magnetosonic waves. Being a semi‐implicit pressure‐based scheme, our new method is therefore particularly well suited for low Mach number flows and for the incompressible limit of the MHD equations, for which it is well known that explicit density‐based Godunov‐type finite volume solvers become increasingly inefficient and inaccurate because of the more and more stringent CFL condition and the wrong scaling of the numerical viscosity in the incompressible limit. We show a relevant MHD test problem in the low Mach number regime where the new semi‐implicit algorithm is a factor of 50 faster than a traditional explicit finite volume method, which is a very significant gain in terms of computational efficiency. However, our numerical results confirm that our new method performs well also for classical MHD test cases with strong shocks. In this sense, our new scheme is a true all Mach number flow solver.

11 December 2017 in Living Reviews in Computational Astrophysics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
DBDinshaw S. Balsara
Dinshaw S. Balsara
As computational astrophysics comes under pressure to become a precision science, there is an increasing need to move to high accuracy schemes for computational astrophysics. The algorithmic needs of computational astrophysics are indeed very special. The methods need to be robust and preserve the positivity of density and pressure. Relativistic flows should remain sub-luminal. These requirements place additional pressures on a computational astrophysics code, which are usually not felt by a traditional fluid dynamics code. Hence the need for a specialized review. The focus here is on weighted essentially non-oscillatory (WENO) schemes, discontinuous Galerkin (DG) schemes and PNPM schemes. WENO schemes are higher order extensions of traditional second order finite volume schemes. At third order, they are most similar to piecewise parabolic method schemes, which are also included. DG schemes evolve all the moments of the solution, with the result that they are more accurate than WENO schemes. PNPM schemes occupy a compromise position between WENO and DG schemes. They evolve an Nth order spatial polynomial, while reconstructing higher order terms up to Mth order. As a result, the timestep can be larger. Time-dependent astrophysical codes need to be accurate in space and time with the result that the spatial and temporal accuracies must be matched. This is realized with the help of strong stability preserving Runge–Kutta schemes and ADER (Arbitrary DERivative in space and time) schemes, both of which are also described. The emphasis of this review is on computer-implementable ideas, not necessarily on the underlying theory.