25 March 2025 in Journal of Primary Care & Community Health
Objective: To compare the diagnostic accuracy and clinical decision-making of experienced community nurses versus state-of-the-art generative AI (GenAI) systems for simulated patient case scenarios. Methods: In the months of 5 to 6/2024, 114 community Israeli nurses completed a questionnaire including 4 medical case studies. Responses were also collected from 3 GenAI models (ChatGPT-4, Claude 3.0, and Gemini 1.5), analyzed both without word limits and with a 10-word constraint. Responses were scored on accuracy, speed, and comprehensiveness. Results: Nurses scored higher on average compared to the shortened GenAI responses. GenAI responses were faster but more verbose, and contained unnecessary information. Gemini (full version) and Claude (full version) achieved the highest accuracy among the GenAI models. Conclusions: While GenAI shows potential to support aspects of nursing practice, human clinicians currently exhibit advantages in holistic clinical reasoning abilities, a skill requiring experience, contextual knowledge, and ability to bring concise and practical responses. Further research is needed before GenAI can adequately substitute nursing expertise.
1 November 2021 in Geriatric Nursing
30 January 2019 in International Psychogeriatrics
Objectives:To examine whether emotional intelligence (EI) is associated with cognitive function (CF) in a sample of community-dwelling, non-demented elderly out-patients.Design:Correlational cross-sectional study.Setting:Two memory clinics in an urban community in central Israel.Participants:Individuals age 60 and older without dementia, recruited from two memory clinics (N = 151).Measurements:Health history was obtained from medical charts. All participants underwent tests measuring CF, basic and instrumental function, general mental ability (GMA), EI, and depression.Results:Mean age of the participants was 79 years (SD = 7.00) with 96 females (63.6%). Mean score for Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) was 21.62 (SD = 3.09) and for EI was 14.08 (SD = 3.30). Linear multiple regression analysis was conducted to examine associations of CF with EI while controlling for gender, age, education, GMA, and Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI). Age, education, GMA, and CCI were significant correlates of CF and accounted for 31.1% of the variance [F(7,143) = 10.8, p<0.01] in CF. EI was added in the second block and was the factor most strongly associated with CF, explaining an additional 9.1% (a total of 40.2%) of the variance in CF [F(8,142) = 13.2, p<0.01].Conclusion:This study is the first to show the association between EI and CF in older adults. Future prospective studies are needed to explicate the possibility of EI as a protective factor against cognitive decline.
11 August 2026 in Geriatric Nursing
9 September 2026 in Current Psychology