Creative practitioners rely on tools to capture and manage ideas as a foundational aspect of their work. However, we have little knowledge about how idea management practices vary in different creative domains. Combining insights from qualitative surveys ( N \(\sim\) 200) and follow-up in-depth interviews ( n \(\sim\) 60) with creative professionals from four domains (interaction design, research, music, and graphics) of creative work, we report on (1) how ideas are externalized in practitioners’ archives, (2) what they consider important when choosing tools to capture ideas, and (3) how these tool collections resemble and differ from each other. Our cross-domain study demonstrates that participants’ tool use reflects idea capture characteristic needs as well as domain-specific views about the creative process. We conclude with a discussion about capturing as an externalizing activity, practitioners’ use of the term ideas , and four suggestions for directions in the design of creativity support tools.
Recent work identified clarity as one of the top quality attributes that notebook users value, but notebooks lack support for maintaining clarity throughout the exploratory phases of the notebook authoring workflow. We propose always-clear notebook authoring that supports both clarity and exploration, and present a Jupyter implementation called Tidynote. The key to Tidynote is three-fold: (1) a scratchpad sidebar to facilitate exploration, (2) cells movable between the notebook and the scratchpad to maintain organization, and (3) linear execution with state forks to clarify program state. An exploratory study (N=13) of open-ended data analysis tasks shows that Tidynote features holistically promote clarity throughout a notebook’s lifecycle, support realistic notebook tasks, and enable novel strategies for notebook clarity. These results suggest that Tidynote supports maintaining clarity throughout the entirety of notebook authoring.