24 January 2025 in ACM Computing Surveys
Passwords remain the primary authentication method in online services, a domain increasingly crucial in our digital age. However, passwords suffer from several well-documented security and usability issues. Addressing these concerns, password managers and two-factor authentication (2FA) have emerged as key solutions. This article examines these methods with a focus on enhancing password security without compromising usability. We utilize an adapted Bonneau et al. (IEEE S&P 2012) framework tailored to the specific challenges of password managers and 2FA. This allows us to categorize and evaluate prominent solutions from both academic research and industry practice, with a focus on their security, privacy, and usability. A crucial aspect of our study involves evaluating the effectiveness of a combined PM+2FA system in balancing security and usability. This study not only examines current trends but also suggests potential areas for future research, offering valuable insights to both users and developers in the evolving landscape of digital security.
30 December 2024 in IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing
Push-based two-factor authentication (2FA) methods, such as the ”Just-Confirm” approach, are popular due to their user-friendly design, requiring users to simply approve or deny a push notification on their mobile device. However, these methods are vulnerable to ”concurrency attacks,” where an attacker attempts to log in immediately after the legitimate user, causing multiple push notifications that may lead to users inadvertently approving fraudulent access. This vulnerability arises because the login notifications are not uniquely bound to individual login attempts. To address this issue, Push-Compare-and-Confirm 2FA method enhances security by associating each login notification with a unique code displayed on both the authentication terminal and the push notification. Users are required to match these codes before confirming access, thereby binding the notification to a specific login attempt. Recognizing the ubiquity of mobile devices in daily life, we conducted a comprehensive user study with 65 participants to evaluate the usability and security of Push-Compare-and-Confirm. The study considered two scenarios: one where the user’s second-factor device (phone) is physically separate from the authentication terminal (e.g., logging in on a PC and confirming on the phone), and another where the phone serves as both the authentication terminal and the second-factor device. Participants completed 24 login trials, including both benign and attack scenarios, with varying code lengths (four characters and six characters). Our results indicate that while Push-Compare-and-Confirm maintains high usability in benign scenarios, with True Positive Rates (TPR) exceeding 95%, it presents significant challenges in attack detection. Participants correctly identified only about 50% of fraudulent login attempts, indicating a substantial vulnerability remains. These findings suggest that although Push-Compare-and-Confirm enhances security over standard push-based 2FA methods, additional measures—such as more intuitive interface designs, clearer visual cues, and user education on the importance of code verification—are necessary to improve attack detection rates without compromising usability.
26 June 2025 in IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security
The most commonly adopted password management technique is to store web account passwords on a password manager and lock them using a master password. However, current online password managers do not hide the account passwords or the master password from the password manager itself, which highlights their real-world vulnerability and lack of user confidence in the face of malicious insiders and outsiders that compromise the password management service especially given its online nature. We attempt to address this crucial vulnerability in the design of online password managers by proposing a cloud-based password manager that does not learn or store master passwords and account passwords. We introduce the protocol design and report on a full implementation of the system. Our implementation provides several security features, including enforcement of a unique and secure password per each service, robustness to online password guessing attacks against the password manager and the web service, robustness to password dictionary attacks upon compromise of the password manager and the web service, and security against phishing attacks. Furthermore, to assess users’ perceptions of the security and usability of our password manager, we conducted a lab-based study. The findings from the study suggest that our system is close to being practical for everyday use and is viewed by users as both usable and more secure/trustworthy.