This article is aimed at developing a proposal of indicators to integrate climate change adaptation into the process of designing legislation and assessing the effectiveness of this legislation in adapting the society, the economy and the environment to climate change. Based on a review of climate change adaptation monitoring indicators used in selected European countries, an assessment of potential indicators according to the proposed criteria was carried out and a proposed list of indicators for monitoring climate change adaptation in selected economic sectors was developed for use in the ex-ante assessment of legislation. The proposed set of indicators can be used for ex-ante assessment of legal acts in terms of implementation of climate change adaptation requirements - both to determine the values of indicators selected for a given sector that are relevant to climate change adaptation, and then to monitor changes in these indicators to assess the effects of implementing legal regulations in terms of supporting the state's climate change adaptation policy.
The increasingly severe effects of climate change have resulted in a shift in countries’ approach to climate policy. From an initial focus on mitigation efforts, adaptation to climate change is now given equal importance. Adaptation policies in individual countries provide for different sets of instruments owing to different natural conditions and climate change impacts and their resulting problems as well as different approaches related to the sociopolitical characteristics of the country. In the paper, we identify and classify adaptation policy instruments and then look for the differences and similarities in the adaptation instrument mixes included in the national adaptation strategic documents of selected European countries. We focused on Western European (WE) and Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries, as the latter are underrepresented in studies on adaptation policies. Based on text-mining methods, i.e., categorisation of policy instruments using a set of criteria and clustering, we looked for similarities and differences between the adaptation instrument mixes in the chosen European countries. We found similarities between the two CEE countries studied—Poland and Lithuania. These countries are also different from WE countries in this regard. The results indicate that CEE countries have a sectoral rather than systemic approach to adaptation policy, and instruments from the management sphere are less prominent.
29 June 2021 in International Community Law Review
For many years the European Union has aspired to be the leader of global climate protection policy. By setting increasingly ambitious challenges in its efforts against global warming, the EU has tried to encourage other countries to compete in this field at international level. In this article, the authors present the roles of the Council of the European Union and the European Commission in the process of concluding international agreements on climate protection. The division of competences between the two institutions is important in the situation when the agreements are concluded within Union’s non-exclusive competence such as the one in the field of environmental protection. In case of such agreements both the Union and its Member States are contracting parties. However, not only the division of competences is at the centre of the EU external action, but also the development of appropriate solutions that will ensure the effective achievement of climate policy objectives.
Może się wydawać, że wybór podstawy prawnej aktu w dziedzinie ochrony środowiska jest sprawą oczywistą i niebudzącą wątpliwości, zważywszy, że kompetencje Unii w tej dziedzinie mają ponad trzydziestoletnią historię, a przy tym są wykonywane intensywnie, na co wskazuje stale rosnąca liczba aktów prawnych regulujących rozmaite zagadnienia z zakresu ochrony środowiska. Jak się jednak okazuje wybór podstawy prawnej aktu w dziedzinie ochrony środowiska może okazać się problematyczny, jeśli weźmiemy pod uwagę warunki stosowania specjalnej procedury ustawodawczej, o której mowa w art. 192 ust. 2 TFUE. Procedura ta znajduje zastosowanie między innymi w odniesieniu do środków wpływających na wybór państwa członkowskiego między różnymi źródłami energii. Do tej pory TSUE nie zaproponował klarownej i spójnej interpretacji art. 192 ust. 2 TFUE w odniesieniu do przesłanek stosowania specjalnej procedury ustawodawczej. W wyroku w sprawie C-5/16 Polska przeciwko Parlamentowi i Radzie Trybunał Sprawiedliwości po raz kolejny mierzył się z tym problemem, niestety i tym razem nie doszło do wytyczenia przekonywujących kryteriów wyboru podstawy prawnej aktu, w sytuacji, gdy akt ten wpływa na wybór państwa członkowskiego między różnymi źródłami energii. W artykule autorki dokonują przeglądu orzecznictwa sądów unijnych dotyczącego wyboru podstawy prawnej aktu. Ustalenia dokonane na tym tle stają się następnie punktem odniesienia przy ocenie wzorca stosowania specjalnej procedury ustawodawczej, który Trybunał zaproponował w sprawie C-5/16.
21 April 2020 in Review of European and Comparative Law
Climate policy is a complexed area of cooperation between Member States and European Union institutions. The ambitious goals that the EU sets for itself in this matter are not always possible to be met by all Member States, hence the ability to work out compromise solutions is of great importance. Member States have different internal conditions, which determine the objectives of their economic and energy policies, therefore they do not always have convergent interests in this area. The decision-making centre where EU climate protection policy is created is: the European Council, where key elements of this policy are agreed (such as reduction targets), and so-called an ‘institutional triangle’, i.e. EU Council, European Parliament and European Commission which are directly involved into the legislative process. This configurations is a platform where cooperation of the Member States manifests itself in various forms and intensity and where these countries may attempt to force their interests in the process of creating EU policy. The authors present the legal bases of the European Union's competences in the field of climate policy and the role of the EU institutions in its creation with particular focus on mechanisms that allow Member States to influence the shape of that policy.