Many equity-deserving populations, including those facing structural health inequities, lack support to participate in clinical trials while facing barrier
Misinformation hinders the impact of public health initiatives. Efforts to counter misinformation likely do not consider the full range of factors known to affect how individuals make decisions and act on them. Implementation science tools and concepts can facilitate the development of more effective interventions against health misinformation by leveraging advances in behavior specification, uptake of evidence, and theory-guided development and evaluation of complex interventions. We conducted a scoping review of misinformation literature reviews to document whether and how important concepts from implementation science have already informed the study of misinformation. Of 90 included reviews, the most frequently identified implementation science concepts were consideration of mechanisms driving misinformation (78%) and ways to intervene on, reduce, avoid, or circumvent it (71%). Other implementation science concepts were discussed much less frequently, such as tailoring strategies to the relevant context (9%) or public involvement in intervention development (9%). Less than half of reviews (47%) were guided by any theory, model, or framework. Among the 26 reviews that cited existing theories, most used theory narratively (62%) or only mentioned/cited the theory (19%), rather than using theory explicitly to interpret results (15%) or to inform data extraction (12%). Despite considerable research and many summaries of how to intervene against health misinformation, there has been relatively little consideration of many important advances in the science of health care implementation. This review identifies key areas from implementation science that might be useful to support future research into designing effective misinformation interventions.
Background.: This study aimed to evaluate the ability of Donation Advisor (DA), a validated clinical decision support tool that uses continuous monitoring, variability analysis, and predictive models, to (i) predict likelihood of successful donation after circulatory determination of death (DCD) before withdrawal of life-sustaining measures (WLSM), and (ii) describe ischemia during WLSM in DCD patients. Methods.: Eligible patients were screened at the 5 sites where DA was implemented. DA reports were generated in real time but shown to clinicians after the donation was complete (noninterventional). Clinicians were interviewed for improvement of the tool. Results.: We enrolled 34 donor patients in the study; 27 had DCD attempts and 20 proceeded to organ recovery. DA reports were generated before WLSM in all 27 attempted DCD patients (100%) while post-WLSM ischemia reports were generated in 26 of 27 DCD attempts (96%). Nineteen of 34 involved clinicians completed interviews, 10 from intensive care, and 9 from transplantation team members. Following a user-centered design approach, feedback was used to create 5 versions. Revisions included additions, removals, clarifications, and formatting changes; the number of revisions decreased with each amendment. The report’s predictive scores were found to be useful by most practitioners (83%). We identified barriers and drivers to use the report in future practice, some of which may be addressed through improved education and awareness. Conclusions.: DA can be deployed in real time during the DCD process. The usefulness and usability of the DA report has improved through user feedback; both barriers and drivers to implementation exist.
Objective: Recruitment to clinical trials involving sickle cell disease (SCD) patients can be challenging, leaving trialists uncertain about how to optimize recruitment approaches and strategies. Informed by the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF), we identified a comprehensive set of barriers and enablers to participation in SCD trials, and suggest how this theory-informed survey approach can improve trial recruitment strategies. Methods: In collaboration with Clinical Trials Ontario and Sickle Cell Awareness Group of Ontario (SCAGO), we conducted a mixed methods study involving interviews with and surveys of SCD patients and families. We iteratively adapted a template survey based on think-aloud interviews, before administering the adapted survey online to SCAGO membership. Results: Fifteen interviews with SCAGO members led to 49 survey items across 13 of 14 TDF domains. Four new items specific to the SCD community were added. Administration challenges led to low survey response, with only 22 people completing the survey. Eighteen items from 8 domains were seen as barriers (e.g., invasive tests/procedures, travel to study site). Twenty-two items from 9 domains were seen as enablers (e.g., hope for a cure, helping others). Conclusion: Our theory-guided approach identified a comprehensive set of factors related to SCD trial participation, information that can support recruitment strategy development prior to trial onset. Low survey response rates precluded strong conclusions about the relative priority of the individual barriers and enablers; more work will be needed among a broader sample of SCD patients and families. Identification of theory-guided behavioural domains offers targeted suggestions for trial recruitment.
Journal of Medical Internet Research - International Scientific Journal for Medical Research, Information and Communication on the Internet #Preprint #PeerReviewMe: Warning: This is a unreviewed preprint. Readers are warned that the document has not been peer-reviewed by expert/patient reviewers or an academic editor, may contain misleading claims, and is likely to undergo changes before final publication, if accepted, or may have been rejected/withdrawn. Readers with interest and expertise are encouraged to sign up as peer-reviewer, if the paper is within an open peer-review period. Please cite this preprint only for review purposes or for grant applications and CVs (if you are the author). Background: Growing evidence has suggested the use of Early Warning Scores (EWSs) which integrate real-time vital sign monitoring, can help Rapid Response Teams (RRTs) proactively identify patients at risk of deterioration. The Visensia Safety Index (VSI) is a novel EWS based on continuous vital sign monitoring. Objective: This study aims to evaluate the trial implementation of a portable continuous vital sign monitoring system paired with a novel machine learning based index to predict potential clinical deterioration. Methods: This two-phase, prospective cohort study will be conducted at the Ottawa Hospital. Eligible patients will be monitored using the VSI with alerts to trigger rapid response team evaluation. Subsequently, we will conduct 30–45-minute semi-structured interviews of consenting healthcare providers to explore the clinical impressions of the trial implementation. Results: As of August 2024 when the protocol manuscript was submitted, we have enrolled 25 patients. Conclusions: The execution of this interventional study requires a multidisciplinary effort. The study employs continuous vital sign monitoring, combined with prediction of deterioration risk, utilized to activate the RRT. Evaluating feasibility and clinical impressions of this trial implementation is the first step of exploring monitoring based predictive decision support.