Greenwashing is more virulent than ever. A profusion of environmental, social, and governance and net zero commitments are becoming fraught with questionable and misleading claims. At the same time, we are no closer to solving the pressing environmental and social issues of our time. In this review, we seek to examine this shift and summarize changes in greenwash research into three key phases: (a) 1.0 Static Communication; (b) 2.0 Dynamic Management; and (c) 3.0 Narratives about the Future. We analyze current key areas of developing literature and point to numerous open questions for future research. Next, we go beyond much of the published work to examine emerging tactics and lay out a forward-looking agenda for future research. We also propose a model of Corporate Miscommunication, integrating various streams in greenwash research. In doing so, we seek to lay a pathway for greenwashing researchers to finally find that elusive “end” to greenwashing.
In the face of both increasing climate risks and growing market opportunities, numerous firms are rushing to trumpet their environmental and social achievements. Many firms are, however, seemingly paradoxically, choosing to minimize or withhold their sustainability accomplishments, an increasingly prominent phenomenon known as brownwashing or greenhushing. We draw on an in-depth qualitative study with over 50 firms in the North American wine industry to offer in situ insights on why and how firms engage in brownwashing. Our findings are a significant departure from prior research that has focused on brownwashing to mitigate negative stakeholder judgments. First, our findings reveal firms frequently engage in brownwashing driven by their own judgments of sustainability, specifically its constraints, branding, and community. Second, our analysis reveals the complex interaction between brownwashing and greenwashing and highlights how rampant greenwashing can cause sustainable firms to withdraw green claims, thus considerably advancing the literature on environmental communications. In short, firms are brownwashing because of rampant greenwashing by others. We then develop a foundational model to integrate previously established mechanisms (avoidance brownwashing) with our newly identified mechanisms (rejection brownwashing). As society seeks to engage firms in transparent reporting of sustainability to address grand challenges, our study offers timely theoretical and practical insights.
23 September 2022 in Leadership & Organization Development Journal
Purpose: Why some people are motivated to become leaders is important both conceptually and practically. Motivation to lead compels people to seek out leadership roles and is a distinct predictor of leader role occupancy. The goal of our research is to determine contextual (socioeconomic status and parenting quality), interpersonal (sociometric status), and personal (self-esteem and gender) antecedents of the motivation to lead among young adults.Design/methodology/approach: The authors tested the model using two samples of Canadian undergraduate students (Sample 1: N = 174, M age = 20.02 years, 83% female; Sample 2: N = 217, M age = 18.8 years, 54% female). The authors tested the proposed measurement model using the first sample, and tested the hypothesized structural model using the second sample.Findings: The proposed 5-factor measurement model provided an excellent fit to the data. The hypothesized model also provided a good fit to the data after controlling for potential threats from endogeneity. In addition, gender moderated the relationship between sociometric status and affective-identity motivation to lead, such that this interaction was significant for females but not males.Practical implications: The findings make a practical contribution in understanding how parents, teachers, and organizations can encourage greater motivation to lead, especially among young adults who have faced poverty and marginalization and tend to be excluded from leadership positions in organizations.Originality/value: The authors conceptualize and test the contextual, interpersonal, and personal predictors of affective-identity motivation to lead among young adults.