Organic compounds can crystallize in different forms known as polymorphs. Discovery and control of polymorphism is crucial to the pharmaceutical industry since different polymorphs can have significantly different physical properties which impacts their utilization in drug delivery. Certain polymorphs have been reported to ‘disappear’ from the physical world, irreversibly converting to new ones. These unwanted polymorph conversions, initially prevented by slow nucleation kinetics, are eventually observed driven by significant gains in thermodynamic stabilities. The most infamous of these cases is that of the HIV drug ritonavir (RVR): Once its reluctant form was unwillingly nucleated for the first time, its desired form could no longer be produced with the same manufacturing process. Here we show that RVR’s extraordinary disappearing polymorph as well as its reluctant form can be consistently produced by ball-milling under different environmental conditions. We demonstrate that the significant difference in stability between its polymorphs can be changed and reversed in the mill—a process we show is driven by crystal size as well as crystal shape and conformational effects. We also show that those effects can be controlled through careful design of milling conditions since they dictate the kinetics of crystal breakage, dissolution, and growth processes that eventually lead to steady-state crystal sizes and shapes in the mill. This work highlights the huge potential of mechanochemistry in polymorph discovery of forms initially difficult to nucleate, recovery of disappearing polymorphs, and polymorph control of complex flexible drug compounds such as RVR.
30 July 2020 in Angewandte Chemie International Edition
We exploit the possible link between structural surface roughness and difficulty of crystallisation. Polymorphs with smooth surfaces may nucleate and crystallise more readily than polymorphs with rough surfaces. The concept is applied to crystal structure prediction landscapes and reveals a promising complementary way of ranking putative crystal structures.
We present a simple way of estimating the entropy cost of solvate formation in crystals. The entropy penalty of making solvates can be as low as <1 kJ mol−1 or as high as >9 kJ mol−1 and is entirely dependent on the nature of the liquid component and the temperature of solvate formation. A link is found between a low entropy cost and a higher likelihood for a solvent to make solvates.
15 October 2025 in Journal of the American Chemical Society
Flexible molecules change their conformations to optimize intermolecular interactions in the solid-state ─a process that comes at an intramolecular energy cost. The interplay between these opposing forces leads to beautifully balanced and elegant crystal structures. Yet, the relationship between intramolecular energy penalties and intermolecular stabilization has not been fully explored, largely because it requires models capable of accurately capturing components with distinct physical origins. In this work, we employ state-of-the-art hybrid DFT models to probe these interactions and quantify their energetic contributions to crystal lattice energies. After benchmarking 18 computational methods, we identify PBE-MBD/B2PLYPD as the method best reproducing experimental polymorph stabilities with mean absolute deviations of just 2.3 kJ·mol-1 across 17 polymorphic pairs. Using this model, we compute and analyze lattice energy partitions for 125 crystal structures spanning a diverse set of flexible compounds. Our analysis reveals a striking empirical trend─the "40% limit"─which shows that up to 40% of the intermolecular stabilization energy can compensate for intramolecular energy penalties associated with conformational variations. Furthermore, the probability of a higher-energy conformation being observed in the solid-state decreases as a function of the intra-to-intermolecular energy ratio and becomes negligible at the 40% mark. These findings are significant: they define the energetic limits of conformational flexibility in the solid-state and the intra-to-intermolecular energy ratios provide a quantitative tool to predict structures. They can be used to guide the conformational phase space sampling for crystal structure prediction, to rank hypothetical structures according to their crystallizability, or to anticipate difficulties of nucleation and crystal growth in crystal forms of flexible compounds.
Classical nucleation theory teaches the idea that molecular clusters form and grow in solution and that depending on prevailing conditions there is a chance for some to grow large enough to overcome the interfacial energy penalty and become mature crystals. However, from such a kinetic analysis, nothing is learnt of the nature of the composition or the molecular packing in such clusters. As a means of addressing this shortcoming consideration has, in the past, been given to the idea that in certain systems crystallography may offer additional, structural, insights. From this approach the notions of ‘nucleation pathway’ or ‘nucleation transition state’ have become useful concepts around which to formulate hypotheses as to how clusters may yield specific molecular packing, resulting for example, in the observation of crystal polymorphs. Here we offer an in-depth crystallographic analysis related to the nucleation of the α and β polymorphs of para-aminobenzoic acid in an attempt to reveal the pathways leading to the two forms. Using a combination of CSD analyses, crystal structure prediction and targeted crystallizations we explore plausible solution pathways to these polymorphs and discuss our results in the light of known kinetic data for the nucleation and growth of this material.