29 May 2021 in Journal of Applied Ecology
The value of non‐commodity ecosystem services provided by forests is widely recognized, but intensive forest management practices are increasing, with uncertain consequences for a multitude of these services. Quantitative relationships among biodiversity conservation, timber production and other ecosystem services remain poorly understood, especially during the early‐successional period of intensively managed forestlands. We manipulated management intensity in regenerating forest plantations to test the prediction that treatments aimed at maximizing timber production decrease biodiversity conservation and non‐timber services. We measured species richness of 3 taxonomic groups and 13 proxies for provisioning, cultural and regulating services within stands randomly assigned to one of the three herbicide application intensities or an untreated control. Herbicides increased allocation of net primary production to crop trees, increasing projected timber volume and revenues at 40‐ and 60‐year harvest ages. Commonly used herbicide prescriptions reduced culturally valued plants by 71%, wild‐ungulate forage by 41%, avian richness by 20% and pollinator floral resources by 42%, the latter being associated with 38% fewer pollinator species. However, agriculturally valued bumblebees, pollination of blueberries, avian‐mediated arthropod control, wild ungulate observations and regulation services tied to forest productivity appeared unaffected by increasing management intensity and timber production. Species richness and flora‐provided services in young forest plantations exhibited strong trade‐offs with projected timber production, whereas post‐treatment vegetation regeneration and site‐level variation likely maintained a range of other services. Although vegetation recovery is important for supporting wildlife and some ecosystem services on industrial forestlands, it is unlikely that any single prescription can optimize both timber and non‐timber benefits to society across managed forest landscapes. Instead, producing different services in discrete portions of the landscape may be necessary. Synthesis and applications. We tested the effects of intensive forest management via herbicides on ecosystem services and found that biodiversity responses and services from early‐successional vegetation trade‐off against timber production. A number of services appeared to be compatible with timber production, although no single prescription optimized the full range of services. Stand‐level biodiversity conservation and a variety of services could potentially be provided by treatment skips and less‐intensive management on productive sites, although it is unlikely that all services can be optimized without landscape‐level planning.
2 April 2025 in Global Change Biology
Soil respiration (Rsoil) is the second largest terrestrial carbon (C) flux, and therefore, it is imperative to understand and quantify its responses to global environmental change. Rsoil consists of two component CO2 fluxes: autotrophic respiration from the metabolic activity of roots (Ra‐root) and heterotrophic respiration (Rh) derived from the metabolic activity of mycorrhizal fungi and microbial decomposition of detritus, soil organic matter, and rhizodeposits. Increased nitrogen (N) availability often reduces Rsoil in forest ecosystems, but it remains unclear which contributing fluxes govern Rsoil responses and if suppression of Rsoil results from increased N availability itself or from the tendency of added N to acidify soil. Here, we address these uncertainties in a long‐term, large‐scale factorial N × pH experiment in six temperate forest stands in central New York, USA. We anticipated that increasing soil N availability would decrease plant belowground C allocation and related root‐associated respiration and that soil acidification would suppress microbial decomposition, thereby reducing Rh. We found that both acidifying and deacidifying N additions suppressed annual Rsoil by 19% and 13%, respectively (−1.8 Mg C ha−1 year−1 overall), but acidification (from pH 4.67 to 4.22) alone did not detectably affect this flux. Annual Rsoil decreased steeply (R2 = 0.66, p < 0.001) as soil N availability increased. Nitrogen additions generally suppressed Rh, especially in the forest floor (−34%), whereas the effects of acidification alone varied by soil depth, with substantial suppression in the forest floor (−33%) partially offset by stimulation at depth. A novel partitioning of Rsoil component responses suggests that N additions suppressed root‐associated respiration by ~1.1 Mg C ha−1 year−1 (62% of the Rsoil suppression), while acidification alone had no effect. Our findings demonstrate that soil N availability, not soil pH, is the predominant biogeochemical control over Rsoil in these temperate forests, with larger responses of plant‐driven C fluxes than microbial‐driven C fluxes.
25 September 2025 in Tree Physiology
Photosynthesis links terrestrial carbon, water and nutrient cycles. Photosynthetic least-cost theory suggests that plants optimize photosynthesis at the lowest summed investments in nutrient and water use. The theory predicts that increasing nutrient availability should increase nutrient allocation toward photosynthetic enzymes and reduce stomatal conductance, allowing similar photosynthetic rates achieved at a lower ratio of leaf intercellular to atmospheric CO2 concentration (χ) and reduced water loss. The theory suggests similar responses to increasing soil pH in acidic soils due to common correlations between soil pH and nutrient availability. However, empirical tests of the theory outside of environmental gradients are rare. To test this theory experimentally, we measured photosynthetic traits in mature Acer saccharum Marshall trees growing in a 9-year, nitrogen-by-pH manipulation in the northeastern USA. Increasing soil nitrogen availability did not affect net photosynthesis (Anet) or stomatal conductance (gs) rates, but was associated with increased area-based leaf nitrogen content (Narea), increased photosynthetic capacity (Vcmax, Jmax) and decreased χ (i.e, increased water-use efficiency). These patterns strengthened the tradeoff between nitrogen and water use, indicated by steeper slopes of Narea–χ and Vcmax–χ with increasing soil nitrogen availability. When examined across all plots, soil pH had no effect on any traits. However, in plots without nitrogen additions, increasing soil pH increased the slopes of Narea–χ and Vcmax–χ, though did not modify χ. Supporting the theory, A. saccharum maintained Anet across the soil nitrogen availability gradient by trading less efficient nitrogen use for more efficient water use. Additionally, the effects of soil pH on nitrogen–water use tradeoffs appear to occur through indirect pH effects on soil nitrogen availability. These results indicate that elevated nitrogen deposition could stimulate photosynthesis less than commonly expected and instead reduce water losses, and conversely, that reductions in photosynthesis expected from increasing nitrogen limitation in some regions could be lessened if accompanied by increased transpiration.
1 January 2025 in Canadian Journal of Forest Research
Fine roots and root-associated carbon (C) inputs contribute disproportionally to soil C stocks. Here, we quantified fine root dynamics in a mixed northern hardwood forest at the Woods Lake Watershed in the Adirondack Park, NY, USA, where an experimental lime application in 1989 led to the near-doubling of forest floor organic matter stocks two decades later. Prior work linked this organic matter accumulation with lower heterotrophic respiration and decreased abundances of major fungal saprotrophs and ectomycorrhizal fungi. We investigated whether liming-driven shifts in fine root dynamics and depth distribution also contributed to forest floor accumulation. Forest floor mass in limed plots again roughly doubled that in unlimed plots 32 years after liming, with persistently large accumulations in the Oa horizon. Liming decreased fine root production across all horizons measured (Oe, Oa, 0–10 cm mineral soil) and by 40% overall, with largest effects in the Oa horizon (−45%) where root turnover was also reduced (−59%). Thus, liming decreased, rather than increased, root detrital C inputs to the forest floor. These results suggest that liming must have suppressed decomposition even more than shown previously or increased some other C input to the forest floor to explain its substantial C accumulation.
7 November 2025 in Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment