Community forest management (CFM) is often a field of encounter between knowledge systems, where a conventional forestry blueprint is frequently applied in contexts rich in traditional ecological knowledge (TEK). This is the case in Mexico, a bioculturally diverse country and a reference of community forestry. Based on a review of laws, policies, literature, and empirical examples, we explore technical, epistemological, political, and contextual dimensions associated with the inclusion and exclusion of TEK in CFM in Mexico. Our analysis is composed of three steps: (1) A diachronic analysis of how TEK and associated practices have been considered by federal forest laws and codes (1960–2018), (2) a diachronic analysis of the scope of conventional forestry and its evolution in time and space, and (3) situated examples illustrating the inclusion and exclusion of TEK in CFM. We argue that: (1) Legal recognition of TEK as a concept does not necessarily entail the legal recognition of all traditional management practices; (2) the inclusion of TEK in CFM is heterogeneous across communities, ecosystems, regions, products and historical trajectories; and (3) different traditional practices are not equally integrated in CFM: traditional practices that contradict the spatial segregation of activities (i.e., land sparing) favored by conventional forestry tend to be less easily accepted or ignored by government institutions.
Tropical montane cloud forests (TMCF) are under severe threat from deforestation, fragmentation and degradation. Several tree species are harvested and commercialized by local communities through unplanned selective logging. Lack of information regarding the growth rates of the most economically valuable timber species hampers the design of effective sustainable management schemes for TMCF. The objective of this study was to determine the diameter growth rates and evaluate the influence of tree size, crown class and neighbouring tree basal area on the growth of common and valuable TMCF timber species. Annual diameter growth was measured during two years in 60 trees (10 to 45 cm in diameter at breast height; dbh) each of Alnus acuminata, Liquidambar styraciflua and Quercus xalapensis, located in two unmanaged secondary TMCF sites in Veracruz, Mexico. High diameter growth rates (centimeter per year [cm yr-1]; mean ± SE) were recorded in the three species; the highest was recorded in A. acuminata (1.62 cm yr-1 ± 0.08 cm yr-1), followed by Q. xalapensis (0.91 cm yr-1 ± 0.07 cm yr-1) and L. styraciflua (0.71 cm yr-1 ± 0.08 cm yr-1). Diameter growth rate was inversely related to the basal area of the neighbouring trees, indicating a negative effect of competition in the three species. Dominant trees had higher growth rates than supressed trees in the three species. The high growth rates recorded in forests with no previous management and the negative effect of basal area of neighbouring trees support the potential for silvicultural management in secondary TMCF.
29 April 2025 in Tropical and Subtropical Agroecosystems
Background: Forest vegetation is used daily to sustain basic family needs and incomes in rural communities. Harvesting vegetative regrowth through coppice, a traditional method to produce firewood and charcoal, guarantees permanent forest cover and rapid regrowth. However, a narrative predominates that sanctions this use and stigmatizes those who produce it, attributing the cause of forest degradation and deforestation. In Mexico there are few studies focusing on this type of forest management and its effects. Objective: To characterize the small forest fragments managed traditionally by coppice in agroforestry plots of Zongolica mountain range, Veracruz, México. Methodology: Forest survey in 16 circular sites measuring tree structure, species composition and regeneration, covering 1 hectare sampled. Results: Eleven tree species used for fuelwood were recorded, two with protection status; Quercus with five species, Q. laurina dominated 94% and Q. rugosa 63% among the sites. The average diameter 29.45±0.68 cm, and total basal area of 77.17 m2/ha-1; regeneration occurs by sprouting from the base of the stump with cutting cycles varying 5 to 20 years. Implications: The structural and composition heterogeneity within these agroforestry plots represent a potential to incorporate this management as a productive restoration strategy. Conclusions: These rural forests are maintained through traditional practices, revealed a local knowledge on tree species and are important for family livelihoods as source of raw material for charcoal and firewood. Attending the development of these forest fragments would ensure management cycles that provide the biomass production required by their owners, while conserving tree diversity at landscape level.