1 December 2008 in Clinical Rehabilitation
Objective: To develop and validate a clinically feasible measure of communication effectiveness for people with any type of communication problem following stroke. Design: Cross-sectional, interview-based, psychometric study, building on the development phase for construction of the Communication Outcome after Stroke (COAST) scale. Setting: A community sample from the northwest of England, UK. Subjects: One hundred and two people with communication problems (aphasia and/or dysarthria) following a stroke, within the previous 4—12 months. Interventions: Administration of the COAST scale, on two occasions, within a two-week period, and collection of demographic and other data relating to disability, degree of aphasia (where appropriate) and hospital diagnosis of aphasia/dysarthria. Main measures: Acceptability (missing values), reliability (internal consistency and test—retest reliability) and item analysis (item redundancy). Results: Ninety-seven (visit 1) and 98 (visit 2) respondents provided usable data for the psychometric analysis. The 29-item COAST scale showed good acceptability (few missing values, sample spread 28—100%), internal consistency and test—retest reliability for the scale (α = 0.95; ICC = 0.90) and its subscales (α = 0.65—0.93; ICC = 0.72—0.88), but possible item redundancy. A revised scale of 20 items was produced, demonstrating good internal consistency and test—retest reliability (α = 0.83—92; ICC = 0.72—0.88). Conclusions: The COAST is a patient-centred, practical and reliable measure that can be used to assess self-perceived communication effectiveness for people with aphasia and/or dysarthria. Further testing on construct validity and responsiveness to change is needed before the measure can be firmly recommended for use within clinical practice and research.
12 October 2003 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
Background: Both direct (clinician to child) and indirect (clinician to carer) approaches are currently used in the management of children with language delay, but there is as yet little evidence about their relative effects or resource implications.Aims: This research project compared the Hanen Parent Programme (HPP) in terms of its effectiveness and consequent suitability for an inner‐city UK population with clinic‐based, direct intervention.Methods & Procedures: Thirty‐seven children aged 2;06–3;06 years with a diagnosis of language impairment and their parents took part in the research project. The children were allocated on a geographical basis to receive therapy either as part of an HPP or in a clinic. Nineteen children and their families took part in one of the five Hanen groups that ran successively over 16 months; 18 children and their families received clinic‐based intervention. The children's language was assessed using the PLS‐3 (UK version) and from an analysis of audio‐taped parent and child interaction at three assessment points, one pretherapy and two post‐therapy over 12 months. Two parent language measures were also analysed.Outcomes & Results: Significant gains in language scores were shown by 71% of the children over 12 months. There were no statistically significant differences in child language scores between the two therapy groups at any assessment point. However, the HPP was twice as intensive (in terms of therapist time) as clinic therapy based on average group size, which has resource implications.Conclusions: Results suggest that there are parent and child factors that need consideration when choosing an appropriate intervention programme for a child with language impairment. Parental expectations, existing interaction style and the level of child language may be important influencing factors.
9 July 2003 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
Background: Adequate assessment of ‘normal variation’ versus ‘abnormal status’ is particularly difficult for clinicians working with young children who are under 5 years of age and who present with slow language development. There is therefore clinical motivation to identify possible key difficulties (or ‘risk markers’) that may distinguish children who are likely to have specific language impairment (SLI) from the variation observed in younger, normally developing children.Aims: The issue of ‘risk markers’ for SLI was explored. It is well known that the issue of markers is controversial. The view presented here is that a risk marker represents a symptom with no assumption about whether the symptom reflects a single cause or that this symptom alone identifies the disorder.Methods and Procedures: The performance of 32 children with SLI was compared with that of 32 younger normal language‐learning children on four potential risk marker tasks: non‐word repetition, digit recall, past tense provision and plural marking.Outcomes and Results: The findings suggest that processing markers, particularly non‐word repetition, have the potential for indicating SLI risk. In particular, children who fall in the bottom quarter of the normal distribution in non‐word repetition (performance below the 25th centile) appear to be at risk of SLI.Conclusions: Although these results need to be interpreted cautiously, the evidence is thought to warrant the use of non‐word repetition tasks in clinical practice.
9 July 2000 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
Sixty‐one children, aged 3;6‐5;0, with developmental phonological disorders (PD) participated in a study comparing the effects of metaphonologically (MET) or articulation‐based (ART) therapy. Maturational effects were controlled for by the inclusion of 59 normally speaking control children of the same age range. Measures of phonological (speech) output and phonological awareness were taken before and after therapy for all subjects and at 3 months post‐therapy for PD children. Results showed that PD children improved significantly in both phonological output and awareness skills across the intervention period compared with control children, but that there was no significant difference on the awareness measure between ART and MET groups. ART and MET groups differed from each other on one measure of speech improvement only, with the ART group making more change than the MET group on individual probe scores. Follow‐up measures for both therapy groups indicated that there was little difference between the groups on phonological awareness change or speech development 3 months after intervention, though there was a trend for MET children to continue to make more long‐term change than the ART group on one output measure. Additional analysis showed that there were generally few significant implications for outcome between PD children with good initial phonological awareness skills and those who initially had poor phonological awareness skills.
29 May 2009 in Clinical Rehabilitation
Objective: To validate a measure of the carer’s perspective of a stroke survivor’s communication in everyday life. Design: Cross-sectional, interview-based, psychometric study. Setting: A community sample from the northwest of England, UK. Subjects: Fifty-eight carers and 58 stroke survivors with communication problems (aphasia and/or dysarthria) following a stroke within the previous 4—12 months. Interventions: Administration of the 20-item Carer Communication Outcome after Stroke (Carer COAST) scale, on two occasions, within a two-week period; the 15-item Carers of Older People in Europe (COPE) Index, the patient Communication Outcome after Stroke (COAST) Scale, and collection of demographic and other data relating to the stroke survivor’s disability (Barthel Index), degree of aphasia (Frenchay Aphasia Screening Test) and hospital diagnosis of aphasia/dysarthria. Main measures: Acceptability (missing values), reliability (internal consistency and test—retest reliability) and construct validity. Results: Carer COAST showed good acceptability (no incomplete items, sample spread 24—100%), internal consistency and test—retest reliability for the scale (a = 0.94; intraclass correlation (ICC) = 0.91) and its subscales (a = 0.78—0.90; ICC = 0.75—0.87), and indicative evidence on construct validity (Carer COAST, COPE subscales and COAST). There were statistically significant correlations between the communication items of Carer COAST and the negative impact of caregiving (rs = —0.29) and the financial difficulties of caregiving (rs = —0.38). Conclusions: The Carer COAST scale has considerable potential as a reliable and valid measure of the carer’s perspective on the communication effectiveness of stroke survivors. Intercorrelations with COPE provide specific evidence of the impact of caring for a person with communication difficulties following a stroke.