Motivation: The increasing volume and frequency of cyberattacks have made it necessary that all computing professionals be proficient in security principles. Concurrently, modern technology poses greater threats to privacy, making it important that technological solutions be developed to respect end-user privacy preferences and comply with privacy-related laws and regulations. Just as considering security and privacy must be an integral part of developing any technological solution, teaching security and privacy ought to be a required aspect of computer science education. Objective: We set out to demonstrate that a project-based capstone experience provides an effective mechanism for teaching the foundations of security and privacy. Method: We developed ten learning modules designed to introduce and sensitize students to foundational sociotechnical concepts related to the security and privacy aspects of modern technology. We delivered the modules in the treatment sections of a two-term capstone course involving the development of software solutions for external clients. We asked the students in the course to apply the concepts covered in the modules to their projects. Control sections of the course were taught without the modules as usual. We evaluated the effectiveness of the modules by administering pre-treatment and post-treatment assessments of cybersecurity knowledge and collecting written student reflections after the delivery of each module. Results: We found that the students in the treatment condition exhibited statistically significant increases in their knowledge of foundational security and privacy concepts compared to those in the control condition without the modules. Further, student reflections indicate that they appreciated the content of the modules and were readily able to apply the concepts to their projects. Discussion: The modules we developed facilitate embedding the teaching of security and privacy within any project-based learning experience. Embedding cybersecurity instruction within capstone experiences can help create a software workforce that is more knowledgeable about sociotechnical cybersecurity principles.
10 January 2025 in Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction
Industry-sponsored capstone experiences that involve developing software solutions create valuable opportunities for students to engage in teamwork and learn important career skills just prior to joining the software workforce. The collaboration and communication in capstone projects, which typically happen in person, were forced to move online during the COVID-19 pandemic. We leveraged the transition to conduct a two-stage mixed-methods study that compared the in-person and online capstone experiences of students (novice software developers) and project sponsors (experienced industry professionals) to understand how novices engage in online collaboration. We uncovered that novices find online collaboration more challenging compared to experienced professionals. The challenges faced by the novices and the misalignment with experienced professionals point to a number of avenues for training novice software professionals on effective engagement in geographically distributed collaboration, which is increasingly the norm in the software industry.
As ethical concerns continue to arise around the design of digital technologies, there is an increasing need to incorporate ethics education into project and capstone courses. While students frequently receive instruction in ethical theory and philosophy, they also need practical tools and strategies that they can apply to their class projects and carry with them into their careers. For example, ethical toolkits can provide frameworks and methods for identifying, discussing, and prioritizing ethical concerns in technology design and development. In this session we will invite participants to share their experiences with incorporating ethics into project-based learning. Participants will be able to review and discuss existing toolkits and methods for incorporating ethics into project courses. Some material for this BoF is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under grant nos. 2419005 & 2046245.