To support various types of User Equipment (UE), 5G networks provide three authentication methods: 5G Authentication and Key Agreement (5G-AKA), Extensible Authentication Protocol AKA’ (EAP-AKA’), and EAP Transport Layer Security (EAP-TLS). Among them, EAP-TLS enables certificate-based mutual authentication, making it suitable for legacy or resource-constrained devices without SIM capabilities. However, EAP-TLS has not been supported by open-source 5G core implementations such as free5GC. In this paper, we present the implementation of EAP-TLS authentication in free5GC, addressing key challenges such as adapting the authentication flow, managing TLS session state, and establishing a certificate-based trust infrastructure. Our implementation extends both free5GC and UERANSIM to support mutual TLS over Non-Access Stratum (NAS) and per-UE session management in Authentication Server Function (AUSF). The experimental results show that the EAP-TLS prototype maintains low overhead, with only up to 11% additional latency compared to existing methods. At scale, the negligible performance impact demonstrates that EAP-TLS is not only technically feasible but also practical for IoT environments, legacy equipment, and enterprise devices without SIMs, enabling secure IoT onboarding, Public Key Infrastructure (PKI)-based integration, and new private 5G network services.