Significance: Human muscle-type acetylcholine receptors are heteropentameric ion channels formed from four evolutionarily related subunits, which assemble with a specific stoichiometry and arrangement. It has long been thought that each of the modern-day subunits are required for function. We dispel this notion by first showing that an ancestral β-subunit can replace both the β- and δ-subunits in human acetylcholine receptors. We then identify a single historical amino acid substitution that eliminates the ability of the ancestral β-subunit to functionally replace the human δ-subunit. Our work experimentally demonstrates how acetylcholine receptor subunit complexity could have evolved and uncovers a form of contingency that is unique to heteromeric protein complexes, in which mutations that “lock in” individual subunits determine future evolutionary paths.