2 January 2023 in Journal of Geography
Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK) is the knowledge teachers use to teach a specific subject to a specific audience. The importance of PCK to quality teaching is widely recognized. However, an overview of research about geography teachers’ PCK is missing. To fill this gap, we conducted a systematic review. We analyzed 43 empirical studies, but only 9 used PCK as a framework. Most studies addressed instructional strategies or teaching orientations. The studies were too diverse to draw conclusions on geography teachers’ PCK in general. But portraits of 16 geography teachers emphasized the necessity of geographical knowledge and teaching experience for PCK-quality.
24 November 2023 in International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education
Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK) is used to describe the knowledge teachers use to teach a specific subject to a specific audience. Although PCK is linked to student success and motivation, relatively little is known about the PCK of geography teachers. Through a mixed methods approach, we surveyed a group of 73 Dutch pre-service teachers in their final year of geography teacher education. We used the PCK-consensus model to address both PCK-on action (teacher knowledge) and PCK-in action (teacher practice). We investigated the former through a CoRe-assignment and the latter through a quantitative survey. Teacher's PCK-in action focussed on teacher-centred lessons with ample attention for visualisations, current events, and efforts to engage students. The results for PCK-on action confirmed the content dependency of PCK. Pre-service teachers chose different geographical topics and used different goals and strategies when teaching these topics. In this context, we also found that they experienced difficulties when teaching controversial issues. In a final step, we combined the results of both methods for 9 teachers in individual PCK portraits. These portraits show that coherence between PCK-elements and, therefore, PCK-quality is still weak for most pre-service teachers. Consequently, their fragile subject matter knowledge seems to influence their developing PCK.
10 September 2025 in The Curriculum Journal
Societal trends such as increased accountability, teacher shortages, and flexibility in learning paths affect the work of teacher educators. This study explores the collective agency of Dutch geography teacher educators as they enact the subject pedagogy curriculum within this rapidly changing context. Whilst teacher agency has been widely studied, research on teacher educators—particularly from a collective perspective—remains scarce. Drawing on Priestley et al.'s ecological approach, this study aims to disentangle teacher educators' collective spaces of agency by means of cultural, structural, and material resources. Using focus group interviews with three teams of geography teacher educators, we identified three key challenges that define their collective spaces of agency: (1) accommodating students' developmental phases, (2) gaining insight into students' internship learning, and (3) the growing divide between subject‐specific and general teacher education. Thematic analysis revealed that teams of educators experience a different sense of agency in each of these spaces, depending on their ability to draw on the available resources. Our findings show that teams of educators draw on strong subject teacher identities (cultural resources) and experience collective agency when enacting subject pedagogy at the course level (structural resources). Their sense of agency is weak at the institutional level, particularly in relation to curricular change. This study contributes to a more profound understanding of teacher educators' collective spaces of agency. Disentangling these spaces can help teams of teacher educators to identify the necessary resources to restore their sense of agency in difficult times.
8 October 2026 in Tijdschrift voor Lerarenopleiders
Lerarenopleiders in het hbo vinden het uitdagend om hun vakdidactisch curriculum goed af te stemmen op de leerbehoeften van studenten. Het is daarom belangrijk om beter zicht te krijgen op die leerbehoefte en hoe deze zich ontwikkelt. Wij onderzoeken de vakdidactisch ontwikkeling van hbo-bachelorstudenten aardrijkskunde en ontwierpen daarbij een rubric als analyse-instrument. Vakdidactische ontwikkeling zien wij als een transformatie van gefragmenteerde naar geïntegreerde kennis, waarbij studenten steeds beter hun didactische keuzes kunnen onderbouwen (vakdidactisch redeneren). In de vakdidactische ontwikkeling van leraren-in-opleiding onderscheiden we vier fasen: novice, advanced beginner, competent en proficient. Gedurende deze ontwikkeling krijgen studenten steeds beter zicht op het leren van hun leerlingen en is er in toenemende mate sprake van samenhang tussen hun doelen en overtuigingen, hun didactische strategieën, hun curriculaire keuzes en de toetsing die daaruit volgt. In dit artikel beschrijven we het ontwerpproces van de rubric, duiden de prestatieniveaus aan de hand van een praktijkvoorbeeld en evalueren het ontwerpproces. Behalve als onderzoeksinstrument kan de rubric lerarenopleiders helpen bij het ontwerpen van het vakdidactisch curriculum.