Recent hikes in fertilizer, feed, and food prices threaten the food security of island-dwelling people who rely heavily on imports to sustain food supply and production. The influx of reactive nitrogen (Nr) through imports increases nitrogen load and degrades the environment. To overcome these problems, a robust and sustainable food system must be developed. In this study, we aimed to evaluate the present nitrogen flow in the food system of Ishigaki Island, located in the subtropical zone of Japan, and propose a measure to improve it based on the nitrogen footprint concept. Results showed that the major Nr-loss pathways for agricultural activity on the island were ‘crop-unused’ (37%) and ‘manure’ (43%). In food production, most of the Nr loss to the environment was related to export products, and less than 30% was related to island consumers. To meet the demand of food supply on the island, 5.1 times greater amount of food Nr than that of produced for island consumers was imported from overseas regions, placing the burden of Nr loss on such regions. We found that agricultural activities on the island mainly used chemical fertilizer; less than 13% of cattle manure was reused. To reduce the influx of Nr, we created a scenario in which 30% of chemical fertilizer was replaced by cattle manure. Results indicated 70% of the cattle manure produced on the island was necessary to achieve this scenario. This system could reduce Nr imports and Nr loss on the island by 16% and 17%, respectively. The proposed food system can be extended to other islands to overcome the recent price hikes and conserve the environment. This study is the first to present a detailed nitrogen flow in the food system of a tropical/subtropical island by using the nitrogen footprint concept.
Issues related to reactive nitrogen (Nr) continue to increase and have exceeded planetary boundaries. Both production- and consumer-level efforts can mitigate Nr loads and inputs. However, only independent evaluations of these efforts have been performed thus far, and the lack of comprehensive evaluations has hindered further reductions in Nr loads and inputs. Therefore, in this study, we applied the food nitrogen footprint to a subtropical island in Japan and evaluated both direct (on-island) and indirect (overseas-related, imported food/feed production) Nr loads and inputs within the food system. The following scenarios were developed: shifting diets toward grains and legumes in imported food, halving food loss and using the remainder as concentrate feed, and replacing chemical fertilizers with cattle manure produced on the island. Altering the composition of imported food, reducing food loss by half, and utilizing the remaining portion as feed effectively reduced the indirect Nr load, while using cattle manure reduced the direct Nr load. Implementing these measures in combination reduced the direct and indirect Nr loads by 15.4% and 30.9% and the direct and indirect Nr inputs by 19.8% and 18.8%, respectively. Therefore, it is essential to implement consumer and production efforts simultaneously rather than independently to optimize the global nitrogen cycle.