Citizen science is mainstream: millions of people contribute data to a growing array of citizen science projects annually, forming massive datasets that will drive research for years to come. Many citizen science projects implement a “leaderboard” framework, ranking the contributions based on number of records or species, encouraging further participation. But is every data point equally “valuable?” Citizen scientists collect data with distinct spatial and temporal biases, leading to unfortunate gaps and redundancies, which create statistical and informational problems for downstream analyses. Up to this point, the haphazard structure of the data has been seen as an unfortunate but unchangeable aspect of citizen science data. However, we argue here that this issue can actually be addressed: we provide a very simple, tractable framework that could be adapted by broadscale citizen science projects to allow citizen scientists to optimize the marginal value of their efforts, increasing the overall collective knowledge.
Birds in the bin: It is by now well accepted that humans are not the only animal to have complex culture, and we have also found that ecological novelty can lead to cultural innovation. Klump et al. documented the emergence of an evolving set of behaviors in response to human-generated resources, specifically garbage bins, in sulphur-crested cockatoos. This finding both documents the existence and spread of complex foraging culture among parrots, a lineage known for high-level cognitive function, and illuminates how the spread of a cultural innovation can lead to regional distinct variations. Science , abe7808, this issue p. 456
Callaghan, C. T., M. B. Lyons, J. M. Martin, R. E. Major, and R. T. Kingsford. 2017. Assessing the reliability of avian biodiversity measures of urban greenspaces using eBird citizen science data. Avian Conservation and Ecology 12(2):12. https://doi.org/10.5751/ACE-01104-120212
Most research investigating the effect of urbanisation on animals infers temporal change by comparing the species composition of present urban habitats with that of nearby ‘natural’ sites. In regions with a long history of human habitation and large human populations, there are sometimes sizeable museum collections that provide direct evidence of the distribution of animals present before urbanisation. This study identifies changes in the bird community of Sydney associated with urbanisation, by comparing the pre-1900 bird community determined from the ornithological databases of the Australian Museum and Museum Victoria, with the bird community of 1998–99 determined from Birds Australia's Atlas database. The major difference in the bird community between the two periods was a shift in body size, with large species comprising a greater proportion of the recent bird community than small birds. The source of this difference was a result of both a relative decline in the small species within bird gro...