1 November 2014 in Biological Conservation
6 May 2013 in Behavioral Ecology
Behavioral differences among individuals are common and are organized into personalities in a wide variety of species. Hypotheses for the coexistence of behavioral differences fall into 3 categories: variation in selection, frequency-dependent selection, and behavioral plasticity. We tested predictions of those hypotheses regarding geographic covariation of behavior with ecology, using a recent (≈40 years) biological invasion of common waxbills (Estrilda astrild). Behavior in tests for exploration and social interaction covaried among individuals, suggesting a behavioral syndrome, although we could only demonstrate within-individual repeatability in the test for social interaction. These 2 behaviors changed geographically with the ecology of sites (degree of climate variation) in an apparently adaptive way, rather than with the direction of invasion. We found behavioral plasticity but showed that short-term plastic effects do not explain geographic divergence. Differential dispersal does not explain geographic divergence either, which is orthogonal to the direction of invasion. Results are best interpreted either as evolved divergences, although a candidate-gene approach could not identify genetic correlates of behavior, or as long-term behavioral plasticity (e.g., effects of rearing environment). In this recent invasion, geographic differences in ecology and behavior equate to repeated and fast changes over time. Thus, fluctuations in ecological conditions, which are common in nature, may have a widespread role maintaining behavioral and personality differences via selection and/or long-term behavioral plasticity.
2 May 2014 in Behavioral Ecology
Sexual selection during range expansions has seldom been investigated, but it could be important for speciation because expansions create peripatric populations and sexual ornaments mediate reproductive isolation. We compared carotenoid-based ornamentation of common waxbills (Estrilda astrild) across a recent biological invasion that is representative of typical expansions, in that it progressed from ecologically favorable environments, where the source populations inhabit, toward less favorable ones. We found that sexual ornamentation and sexual dichromatism augmented during the expansion, involving an increase in male color saturation and decrease in female ornamental area. We disfavor explanations based solely on environmental effects or differential dispersal because of the opposite changes in each sex and because environmental factors alone (availability of dietary carotenoids) would predict decreased ornamentation. Results instead suggest increasing sexual selection along the expansion. Sexual signals generally allow female choice of high-quality males and, thus, intersexual selection may increase during expansions because the fitness differential between mating with high- or low-quality males is larger in less favorable environments. This is potentially a general mechanism that, if it proves common, could have implications for macroevolution (e.g., young peripatric species having more elaborate sexual traits).
23 November 2014 in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
1 May 2013 in Acta Oecologica
1 May 2016 in Royal Society Open Science
Sexual signals often compromise camouflage because of their conspicuousness. Pigmentation patterns, on the contrary, aid in camouflage. It was hypothesized that a particular type of pattern—barred plumage in birds, whereby pigmented bars extend across feathers—could simultaneously signal individual quality, because disruptions of these patterns should be perceptually salient at close range and help assess plumage condition. Here we show that common waxbills (Estrilda astrild), which have extensive barred plumage, have more regular patterns as adults than as juveniles, and that adult males have more regular patterns than females. Both these differences are indicative of sexual signalling in species with conventional sex roles. More regular barred plumage was related to better body condition in adult males. Colour ornamentation traits were also related to aspects of quality, either the same as barred plumage (body condition) or a different one (good feather development), supporting both the ‘redundant message’ and the ‘multiple message’ hypotheses for the coexistence of multiple sexual signals. Although receiver responses to the regularity of barred plumage were not studied here, research on other species has shown that barred plumage can mediate social interactions. We conclude that using barred plumage as a signal of quality helps circumvent the functional compromise between camouflage and communication.