The potential for mixed method approaches to offer a creative way to generate theory about human behavior in a complex social world has been observed but rarely executed in a way that is reflexive about either the procedures or its contribution. The analysis reported illustrates the untapped potential for the development of classic grounded theory with mixed method research approaches involving the evaluation of educational and health-related interventions. The analysis contributes to the literature by proposing a model that conceptualizes a fully integrated mixed method approach to grounded theory and introduces ideas about the potential for integration to occur at multiple stages in the research process. Discordant data can contribute to the development of more creative and nuanced theoretical models.
7 September 2020 in International Journal of Social Research Methodology
Little attention has been paid to the processes that are involved in making sense of the role dissonance between sources of data has played in the development of theoretical insight. This methodologically oriented investigation considers an unusual set of case exemplars that used mixed methods and dialogic forms of mixing in ways that produced incremental or rupture theorizing. Six of seven used dialogic forms of mixing, including through visual displays, in ways that formatively advanced the analysis. Findings invite readers to consider the advantages of an open and creative approach to mixed methods that embrace the challenges presented by unexpected findings.
We advance the idea that with the commitment to the intentional engagement of multiple sources of data or analytical procedures to explore complex problems as its core defining feature, the field of mixed methods may now be at a point that we can consider it as an inquiry logic that has the potential to spawn the construction of new methodologies. The special issue invites further conversation that builds on the challenge of mixing at the methodological level.
This methodological article expands the conversation about the contribution of joint displays in theoretically driven mixed method research in psychological fields. The author makes a distinction between basic displays that align qualitative and quantitative data or findings side-by-side from more dynamic displays that are used as analytical tools. Highlighting three examples, the article illustrates the contribution of three types of joint displays to advancing theoretical insight: an integrated results display, a theory to design display, and a theory to finding display. The examples featured demonstrate that joint displays can be complex without necessarily being messy. Implications for mixed methods research and practical suggestions for enhancing joint displays are discussed. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).