Agro-industrial wastes can be transformed into low-cost agricultural inputs while mitigating environmental risks associated with improper disposal. Bell pepper (Capsicum annuum L.) is a vegetable of high economic importance, widely consumed in Brazil and worldwide. This study evaluated the effect of organic fertilizers derived from agro-industrial wastes on bell pepper cultivation in two soil types: Dystrophic Yellow Oxisol and Quartizarenic Neosol. Two fertilizers were tested: PSSD, made with spent mushroom substrate from oil palm waste combined with compost from the dairy industry, and SSSD, produced with spent mushroom substrate from sisal waste combined with the same compost. Fertilizer doses ranged from 0 to 60 t ha⁻¹, alongside a chemical fertilizer treatment (60 N, 300 P, 240 K kg ha⁻¹). Plant growth parameters, including height, stem diameter, number of leaves, flowers, fruits, and biomass, were assessed. Nutrient concentrations (N, P, K, Ca, Mg, S) were measured at flowering (45 days after transplanting). Although chemical fertilization improved initial plant development, it resulted in lower fruit yields. Organic fertilizers, particularly PSSD and SSSD at 60 t ha⁻¹, significantly increased plant biomass and nutrient content, enhancing fruit yield by 62 % compared to chemical fertilization in Quartizarenic Neosol. Organic fertilization with these materials, starting at 30 t ha⁻¹, promoted greater dry matter accumulation and productivity. Overall, the study demonstrates the potential of PSSD and SSSD as sustainable fertilizers for bell pepper production, especially in sandy soils such as Quartizarenic Neosol.