Mechanical testing is widely used to characterise biological and engineered materials, yet a lack of standardisation in data processing and analysis limits reproducibility, comparability, and efficiency across laboratories. To address this, we developed MechAnalyser, a standalone software application that provides automated analysis of mechanical testing data and includes visual and interactive quality control and extensibility for future experiment types. MechAnalyser currently quantifies Young’s modulus (from compression-to-failure and micro-indentation experiments), failure properties (ultimate strength, strain, and force), time of constant decay (𝜏), toughness, and energy dissipation. Accuracy and efficiency were evaluated in a comparison experiment where seven independent users analysed heterogeneous datasets using both their own manual workflows and MechAnalyser. Users analysed Young’s modulus and 𝜏 while recording the dataset preparation and analysis times. Automated analysis using MechAnalyser produced high-quality fits across a broad mechanical range for Young’s modulus and 𝜏 and substantially reduced preparation and analysis time for all users compared with manual methods, while limiting user-dependent variability. These results demonstrate that MechAnalyser provides a robust, time-efficient, and reproducible approach to mechanical data analysis and offers a practical step toward standardised mechanical analysis workflows for biomaterials.