Background: Inverted papilloma (IP) is an uncommon tumour that usually arises in the sinonasal cavity, however rarely it may involve the temporal bone. Its scarcity has meant there is a limited understanding of this disease and an ill-defined approach to management. Methods: An institutional experience with two cases of this rare condition is presented followed by a systematic review of the literature regarding management of IP of the temporal bone (IPTB). A review of the literature was performed for IPTB with collation and analysis of clinical, pathologic, and treatment outcomes. Results: Fifty suitable studies were identified, containing a total of 57 cases, including the two cases presented in this review, of IPTB for analysis. The mean age at presentation was 53.4 years (SD: ±16.3) and the male to female ratio was 1:0.9. Dysplasia or malignancy was seen in 42.1% of cases, and human papilloma virus (HPV) positivity in 43.4% of cases tested. 94.7% of cases were treated by various surgical approaches, with radiation or chemotherapy or both being used in 26.3% of cases. Subgroup analysis of primary and secondary IPTB showed differences in clinicopathologic features and treatment outcomes. Discussion: Complete surgical excision is the recommended management, but the ideal approach is yet to be defined. Adjuvant therapy should primarily be considered in the setting of malignant transformation.