Modern DNS has evolved beyond traditional name resolution, increasingly serving as a carrier for structured metadata and service-discovery information. This functional enrichment inevitably drives sustained growth in DNS response payloads. While essential for modern ecosystem features, this growth is also making DNS response size the center of amplification risk. Despite its importance, the behavior of response size in the wild remains poorly understood, and we still lack a global, systematic view to guide its configuration and control. To this end, we conduct a year-long measurement of response-size behavior across about one million open DNS resolvers. We characterize the UDP response-size limits enforced by these resolvers and find that they cluster around a small set of common values. We also demonstrate how configuration changes at major public resolvers propagate across the DNS ecosystem. We further show that regional differences in resolver response-size limits lead to uneven amplification risk and expose fundamental limitations of existing static and upstream-based defenses. This complex response behavior stems from the tension between mitigating amplification risk through small fixed response-size limits and supporting diverse applications that require large responses. To address this tension, we propose Adaptive Response Scaling (ARS), a lightweight dynamic response-control mechanism that reduces amplification by over 70% while preserving DNS functionality.