Side-blotched lizards ( Uta stansburiana ) play a biological rock-paper-scissors game in which three differently colored male morphs utilize alternative mating strategies. We identified the genetic basis of this polymorphism, which was previously posited to arise from three alleles at one locus. Orange usurper and blue mate-guarder morphs are associated with two divergent haplotypes in the regulatory region of the sepiapterin reductase gene, but yellow sneaker morphs appear to arise through phenotypic plasticity from the same genetic background as blue morphs. Our simulations show that rock-paper-scissors dynamics can better maintain a polymorphism with a genetic system of two alleles plus plasticity than with a three-allele system. This form of balancing selection that combines genetic determination with phenotypic plasticity expands the possibilities for how stable polymorphisms arise in nature.
Premise: Understanding how plants successfully diversified in novel environments is a central question in evolutionary biology. Linanthus occurs in arid areas of western North America and exhibits extensive floral trait variation, multiple color polymorphisms, differences in blooming time, and variation in life history strategies. We reconstructed the evolutionary history of this genus.Methods: We generated restriction‐site associated (ddRAD) sequences for 180 individuals and target capture (TC) sequences for 63 individuals, with complete species sampling. Using maximum likelihood and pseudo‐coalescent approaches, we inferred phylogenies of Linanthus and used them to model the evolution of phenotypic traits and investigate the genus's geographic speciation history.Results: Relationships are consistent and well supported with both ddRAD and TC data. Most species are monophyletic despite extensive local sympatry and range overlap, suggesting strong isolating barriers. The non‐monophyly of the night‐blooming and perennial species may be due to rapid speciation or cryptic diversity. Perenniality likely evolved from annuality, a rare shift in angiosperms. Night‐blooming evolved three times independently. Flower color polymorphism is an evolutionarily labile trait that is likely ancestral. No single geographic mode of speciation characterizes this diversification, but most species overlap in range, which suggests that they evolved in parapatry.Conclusions: Our results illustrate the complexity of phylogenetic inference for recent radiations, even with multiple sources of genomic data and extensive sampling. This analysis provides a foundation for understanding aridity adaptations, such as evolution of flower color polymorphisms, night‐blooming, and perenniality, as well as speciation mechanisms.
Premise: Understanding how arid-adapted plants have diversified in harsh environments is a central question in evolutionary biology. Linanthus (Polemoniaceae) occurs in biodiverse dry areas of Western North America and exhibits extensive floral trait variation, multiple color polymorphisms, differences in blooming time, and variation in life history strategies. Here, we reconstruct the evolutionary history of this group. Methods: We generated restriction-site associated (ddRAD) sequences for 180 individuals and target capture (TC) sequences for 63 individuals, with complete species sampling. Using maximum likelihood and pseudo-coalescent approaches, we inferred phylogenies of Linanthus and used these phylogenies to model the evolution of phenotypic traits and investigate the geographic speciation history of this genus. Key results: Shallow relationships are consistent and well supported with both ddRAD and TC data. Most species are monophyletic despite rampant local sympatry and range overlap, suggesting strong isolating barriers. The non-monophyly of some species is possibly due to rapid speciation or issues with current species delimitation. Perenniality likely evolved from annuality, a rare shift in angiosperms. Night blooming evolved three times independently. Flower color polymorphism is an evolutionarily labile trait and is likely ancestral. No single geographic mode of speciation characterizes the radiation but most species overlap in range, suggesting they evolved in parapatry. Conclusions: Our results illustrate the complexity of phylogenetic inference for recent radiations, even with multiple sources of genomic data and extensive sampling. This analysis provides a foundation to understand aridity adaptations, such as evolution of flower color polymorphisms, night blooming, and perenniality, as well as speciation mechanisms.